EGAT's Thaitanic by Ken Albertsen - HTML preview

PLEASE NOTE: This is an HTML preview only and some elements such as links or page numbers may be incorrect.
Download the book in PDF, ePub, Kindle for a complete version.

>>>>   Thailand’s neighboring countries have it or are planning to get it.  Neighbors further away, such as China and Japan are fully committed to nuclear.  No matter that Japan has had some safety breaches – one as recently as July 2007 (note: this booklet was written before the Fukushima nuclear disaster in Japan), where a very large reactor suffered leaks caused by an earthquake. The leaks weren’t so dangerous, but Japanese authorities waited many hours before informing the public.  China may have had its share of mishaps, but we may never know, as it’s a closed society.  Chinese authorities would not disclose bad news unless it was forced to, or had no alternative.  In other words, if authorities can away with hushing up radiation leaks, they’ll surely do so. 

 

     Indonesia and Vietnam want to go nuclear.  Even cash-strapped Burma announced, in the summer of 2007, its plans for building a nuclear plant with Russian assistance. A big reason why Thailand’s officials are so determined to go nuclear is the fact that many other Asian countries are going that route, and Thailand is worried it will lose prestige by not joining the crowd. 

 

more reasons why Thai authorities are so determined to go nuclear……

 

>>>>   Nuclear promises very large contracts.  Where there are large contracts, there are large pay-offs.  In Thailand, one goes hand in hand with the other.  No exceptions.

 

>>>>   Lucrative contracts extend beyond the plant construction – …on to fuel supply, maintenance, security, to disposal of waste, to eventual decommissioning of the plant.

 

 

     The following info mentions some of the cutting edge

 technologies and companies dealing with ‘concentrated solar’

 

If this entire text mentioned nothing else, it would be useful to just have this list.

It was culled from the URL

http://peswiki.com/index.php/Directory:Concentrated_Solar_Power

which is an offshoot of Wikipedia.net.   

 

       Solar Concentrators can be divided into several categories, among them; photovoltaic systems and thermal systems. Photovoltaic systems (a.k.a. ‘solar panels or PV panels) turn light directly into electricity.  The pretty blue panels you see in some shops (though rarely seen in Thailand) are great.  But advances in PV panels are happening at a phenomenal clip.  Vast ‘solar parks’ with thousands of large PV panels are being developed in SW America, Western Europe, Australia and other locales.  Will Thailand get on board?  Let’s hope so.

 

Thermal systems use the concentrated sunlight to create heat which typically turns a turbine.  One popular design uses salt which quickly gets molten by the intense focused heat of a field of mirrors.  Which would you rather have powering turbines in your town, water heated by molten salt, or water heated by radioactive yellowcake? 

 

 

Forget Lightning. How Do We Catch Sunshine in a Bottle?

 

Renewable power is inspiring clever new ways to store electricity—and to uncork it exactly when and where it is needed.

 

by Maggie Koerth-Baker

 

From Discover Magazine, June 2009 issue

published online at http://discovermagazine.com/2009/jun/18-forget-lightning-how-do-we-catch-sunshine-in-a-bottle

 

Renewable energy has a critical role to play in reducing greenhouse gases and leading the United States toward energy independence. That role should soon be getting bigger: The U.S. government is pushing for a 100 percent increase in renewable energy by 2012. The two biggest sources are the wind and the sun. But the variable nature of wind and solar energy can cause problems with matching supply to demand—problems that would be greatly eased if only we had a really good way of storing electricity on an industrial scale. Currently there are several storage systems vying for dominance.

 

Compressed-Air Energy Storage

At night, when the strongest winds blow and customers are sleeping, unused wind-generated electricity can run giant compressors, forcing large amounts of air into sealed underground spaces. When demand rises during the day, the compressed air can be used to spin turbines, turning the energy back into electricity. Georgianne Peek, a mechanical engineer at Sandia National Laboratories in New Mexico, says this technology can provide a lot of power over long periods of time at a relatively low cost. The technology is also well established: Two compressed-air storage plants have been in operation for decades. The McIntosh Unit 1 plant in McIntosh, Alabama, went online in 1991; a similar plant in Germany has been running since the 1970s. McIntosh 1 can reliably put out 110 megawatts for 26 hours. (One megawatt is enough power to supply roughly 600 to 1,000 typical American homes.)

 

The compressed-air system does have its drawbacks. For one, it does not completely eliminate the need for fossil fuels, because the associated electric generators use natural gas to supplement the energy from the stored compressed air. Compressed-air storage systems also require an airtight underground space, limiting the locations where they can be installed. The two existing compressed-air plants use natural salt domes. Engineers flushed the domes with water to dissolve the salt, then pumped out the brine to create a nicely sealed cavern. But salt dome formations are not plentiful, so researchers are investigating other inexpensive ways to create storage chambers. A facility proposed for Norton, Ohio, would use an abandoned limestone mine. Another, in Iowa, would pump air into drained natural aquifers. Abandoned oil wells and depleted natural gas reservoirs might also work, Peek says, as long as they are not too remote to be hooked into the electrical grid.

 

Molten Salt Heat Exchanger

The sun, like the wind, is a variable source of energy, disappearing at night and ducking behind clouds at inconvenient moments. Thermal storage systems, such as molten salt heat exchangers, mitigate those problems by making solar power available anytime.

 

Right now only one example exists: Spain’s Andasol Power Station, which began operating last fall. Andasol has about 126 acres’ worth of trough-shaped solar collectors that focus the sun’s heat onto pipes full of synthetic oil. The hot oil is piped to a nearby power plant, where it is used to generate steam. During the day, some of the oil is used to heat a mixture of liquid nitrate salts (made by combining elements like sodium and potassium with nitric acid) to temperatures above 700 degrees Fahrenheit. These liquid salts can retain their heat for weeks in insulated tanks. When the collectors cannot generate enough power to meet demand, the salts are drawn out from the tanks and their heat is tapped to run the power plant. A full stockpile of molten salts can keep the Andasol plant running at top capacity—50 megawatts of electricity—for up to seven and a half hours.

 

Molten salt backup systems make solar power more flexible and reliable, says Frank Wilkins of the U.S. Department of Energy’s Solar Energy Technologies Program. Wilkins says that thermal storage systems can increase a solar plant’s annual capacity factor (the percentage of time, on average, that the plant is operational) from 25 percent to up to 70 percent. Expense is the biggest drawback. The Andasol Power Station cost about $400 million, and that was just for phase one of a planned three-phase project. But costs may come down as more plants are built. This past February, the Arizona Public Service power utility announced plans to construct a power station similar to Andasol. It is expected to go online in 2012.

 

Sodium-Sulfur Batteries

Sodium-sulfur batteries work much the same way as the lead-acid battery that starts your car; both use chemical reactions to store and produce electricity. The difference lies in the materials used. Lead-acid batteries contain a lead plate and a lead dioxide plate (the electrodes) in a bath of sulfuric acid (the electrolyte). A reaction between the lead and the acid creates the electric current. Lead-acid batteries are simple and reliable, but they are impractical to use on wind farms because of the amount of space and power electronics they would require.

 

    The sun is a variable source of energy, disappearing at night. Thermal storage systems make solar power available at any time.

 

Sodium-sulfur batteries, which use molten sodium and sulfur as electrodes and a solid ceramic electrolyte, have a higher energy density. “Lead-acid batteries are cheaper,” Peek says. “But you can get the same amount of energy in a smaller amount of space with sodium-sulfur—and that’s important, because real estate costs money too.” Sodium-sulfur batteries can also be charged up to the maximum and discharged completely, which makes them more efficient. And they last about 20 years, versus three to five years for lead-acid.

 

Some U.S. utility companies, including Xcel Energy, have installed small-scale combinations of wind farms and sodium-sulfur batteries. (American Electric Power’s is not yet operational.) Excess electricity from the wind farms can be stored in the batteries and fed into the system later, when wind is low and demand is high. Each battery system, which is roughly the size of a semitrailer, can store about one megawatt and discharge it over six to eight hours. The downside, again, is cost, which is high in part because there are no American companies making sodium-sulfur batteries; the only manufacturers are in Japan.

 

Zinc bromide and vanadium redox flow batteries are other promising technologies. Although not as far along in development as sodium-sulfur, they may be easier to scale up. Vanadium batteries may also charge and discharge more quickly than sodium-sulfur, so they might be better suited to smoothing out power fluctuations caused by rapidly changing weather.

 

Hydrogen

Hydrogen-based energy storage looks great on paper: Use electricity to split hydrogen out of water, then convert the hydrogen back into electricity in a fuel cell when needed. Alas, the underlying technology is expensive and complicated, but MIT chemist Daniel Nocera may have found a better way. His hydrogen-ion-creating system uses an indium tin oxide electrode and a container of water with cobalt and potassium phosphate mixed in. Put the electrode in the water and add voltage. Cobalt, potassium, and phosphate migrate to the electrode, forming a catalyst that begins splitting water molecules into oxygen gas and hydrogen ions. Unlike most existing systems, the materials are fairly inexpensive, and the catalyst renews itself so it lasts a long time.

 

Nocera is still seeking a cheap way to convert hydrogen ions into hydrogen gas and an efficient way to get electricity from photovoltaic panels to the catalyst. But he thinks his approach will help other pieces of the hydrogen infrastructure fall into place. “The discovery opens doors we haven’t been able to walk through before,” Nocera says. “I don’t think this will be as hard.”

 

 

 

* * * * * * *

 

15.  Solar for Power Generating Plants

 

 

image013.jpgAusra    is at the vanguard of large scale power generation. Its solar storage system generates power at centralized stations using concentrating solar power to create steam that turns a turbine to make electricity. It also stores hot water that a power plant can draw on during times when the sun is not shining, reducing the cost to 8 cents per kilowatt hour, compared to 12 cents for natural gas.  http://www.ausra.com/

 


Solar Two
has built a 10-megawatt Solar Two power tower pilot plant near Barstow, California. It collects and stores concentrated solar energy in molten salt and generates electricity when needed by the utility and its customers. The unique storage capability allowed solar energy to be collected when the sun is shining and electric power to be generated even when the sun is not shining.

Details: http://www.energylan.sandia.gov/sunlab/Snapshot/STFUTURE.HTM

 

 

image015.jpg SkyFuel was awarded a grant by the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) to develop its advanced Concentrating Solar Power system known as the Linear Power Tower for utility-scale solar thermal power plants. LPT is a high-temperature linear Fresnel system with molten salt storage. The diagram at left looks like a grill for an air conditioner, but it actually shows a football pitch-sized array of solar mirrors.

 

 

image017.jpg HelioDynamics   uses solar concentrators use mirror banks which concentrate solar radiation onto a receiver unit to produce heat or a combination of heat-and-power. They are designed to be mounted on roofs, on parking lots and in open-field sites. Units can be added to produce MW capacities of power. http://www.hdsolar.com/ -

 

 

 

image019.jpg

Nevada Solar One is a 64-megawatt power plant outside of Las Vegas, Nevada which supplies electric power to the municipal grid.  Acciona Solar Power built the plant.  Press Release:  http://news.com.com/Solar+thermal+energy+making
+a+comeback/2100-11392_3-6189468.html?tag=cd.lede -

 

 

 

 

image021.jpgEMCORE Received a $24 Million Purchase Order for Concentrator Solar Cells from Green and Gold Energy

EMCORE Corporation has been awarded an order for 3 million solar cells for use in GGE's SunCube(TM) terrestrial concentrator system. This 105 MW purchase order represents the largest procurement of concentrator solar cells in the industry to date. http://biz.yahoo.com/prnews/070806/nym035a.html?.v=3
EMCORE attained a record 39% conversion efficiency under 1000x concentrated

illumination on its multi-cell products currently in high volume production.
http://www.emcore.com/

 

 

* * * * * * *

 

16.  Concentrated Solar

 

November 2010 – The Concentrated Solar Power plant of Ain Beni Mathar is now supplying electricity to the Moroccan grid. Located in the East of Morocco near the Algerian border, it will provide numerous lessons for further diffusion of concentrated solar power technology. This plant uses a cutting edge design, combining a large array of 224 parabolic mirror collectors concentrating sun energy and boosting the steam output needed to produce electricity in this 470MW facility. Two other plants with similar design will soon be commissioned in Egypt and Algeria. Source: http://web.worldbank.org/WBSITE/EXTERNAL/COUNTRIES/MENAEXT/MOROCCOEXTN/0,,print:Y~isCURL:Y~contentMDK:22750446~menuPK:294545~pagePK:2865066~piPK:2865079~theSitePK:294540,00.html

 

image023.jpgLos Alamos Renewable Energy   - Solar Reduction of

Carbon Dioxide (SOLAREC™) produces fuel while simultaneously producing electricity from solar energy, at a cost competitive with fossil fuel generated power. The fuel can be burned at night to produce power 24/7 with no environmentally harmful by-products. The process has an over-all efficiency of nearly 48%.   http://www.lare.us/

Compare the aforementioned 48% efficiency with the efficiency of nuclear. If all the factors for nuclear are factored in (mining, processing, shipping, security, plant maintenance, insurance, dealing with radioactive waste, eventual decommissioning of nuclear, etc.)  …..the resultant efficiency of nuclear would probably under 6%.

 

 

image025.jpgMenova Energy   developer of the Power-Spar® solar concentrator can be configured for electricity, heat, cooling and/or lighting solutions. It consists of a parabolic trough reflector which concentrates the sun's energy onto a modular absorber. Capable of capturing up to 80% of the sun's energy, Power-Spar systems can reduce energy bills by as much as 70%.  http://www.power-spar.com

 

SpectroLab  has continued to produce world-record (terrestrial)

concentrator cells, the latest of which is the 40.7% efficient http://www.spectrolab.com/

 

PhotoVolt – features Vertical Multi-Junction (VMJ™) solar cells for photovoltaic power systems that are cost-competitive with traditional fossil-fuel sources of electricity. A postage stamp size VMJ cell delivers 100 watts at 1000 suns.
Press Release:  http://users.adelphia.net/~esch/index.html

 

AzurSpace  has developed Triple Junction Cells on Ge Substrate for Concentrations up to 1000x. Supplier for commercial and large scale systems via SOL3G  http://www.sol3g.com/       http://www.azurspace.com/

 

 

* * * * * * *

 

17.  Solar Thermal Systems

 

 

image027.jpg Schott      is a pioneer in developing receivers for Solar Thermal Power Plants – the heart of solar power systems. Schott built the first Solar Thermal Parabolic Trough Power Plant in The U.S.    The photo shows a large acreage tract of mirrors, all directing the sun’s rays on one spot – which in turn gets very hot.  That’s basically what electricity generation is about; generate high heat to power generators.  http://schott.com 

 

 

Solargenix     Nevada Solar One has built a 64-megawatt Solar Thermal Electric Generating Plant located in Boulder City, Nevada.  Also by Solargenix:  The Winston Series Compound Parabolic Collector (CPC) using non-imaging optics to focus sunlight onto a high efficiency absorber tube. Can be used for solar water heating, space heating and solar cooling applications. http://www.solargenix.com/  

 

 


image029.jpgThe Saguaro Solar Generating Station uses rows of parabolic mirrors to focus the sun’s rays onto SCHOTT PTR 70® receivers, enabling the generation of clean electricity.

 

 

 

 

image031.jpgSolel’s Mojave Solar Park  is a 553 megawatt solar thermal plant on 6,000 acres (15,000 rai) of the Mojave Desert, Arizona. The plant will use Solel's solar thermal parabolic trough technology which has powered nine operating solar power plants in the Mojave Desert and is currently generating 354 MW of annual electricity.  http://www.solel.com/




Note:  Thailand’s EGAT, and their friends have often said that one of the main reasons solar isn’t practical for Thailand is that it’s not suited for large scale.
Proof of the ridiculousness of that myth is Solel (just one company), which has built solar plants generating over 900 MW of electricity.  That’s enough juice for millions of Thai homes, and the resultant price per Kw/Hr is considerably lower than nuclear.  Not only that, the generating capacity can be ramped up simply by adding more trough mirrors.  Does Thailand have space to set up mirrors?  A solar site doesn’t even have to be flat ground.  There are even solar designs which float above the ground, thereby allowing crops and/or grazing animals beneath – but let’s not get too far ahead of ourselves now.

 

 

 

image033.jpgSolucar      600-mirror Solar Tower  in Seville Spain is the first  commercial concentrator station in Europe. It focuses

Sunlight onto water pipes at the top of a 40-storey concrete

tower, which drives a turbine to generate 11 megawatts of

electricity. Thousands more mirrors will be added to further

boost the output. Added details:  http://www.solucar.es/    

 

 

Shuff Steel from Phoenix Arizona, is in partnership with Stirling Corporation building a solar farm located north of Los Angeles.  It is to produce 500 megawatts of power from 20,000 25-kilowatt Stirling solar dishes that are 38 feet tall. The project includes an option where the farm could be expanded to 850 megawatts and 34,000 dishes. Rather than PV panels, the solar farm’s panels harnesses heat from the sun with 82 mirrors and reflect it toward a series of hydrogen-filled tubes that expand when heated. The expanding gas cycles back and forth from cold to hot, and its movement powers a piston that creates up to 25 kilowatts of power.

 

The deal mentioned above is in close coordination with Southern California Electric (SCE) which is a municipal power company, serving a similar function for California, as EGAT does for Thailand.  SCE has a voter-imposed mandate that 20% of its electric power must be from alternative sources by the year 2017. 

Even before this new solar farm (me