The Dragon in Medieval East Christian and Islamic Art by Sara Kuehn, Sebastian Günther, et al - HTML preview

PLEASE NOTE: This is an HTML preview only and some elements such as links or page numbers may be incorrect.
Download the book in PDF, ePub, Kindle for a complete version.

chapter five

tains in southern Armenia The mythical creature

of the zodiac, as discussed below It may be sur-

has a powerful, perhaps bovine, quadruped body

mised that these depictions, other than those in

structure, topped by a slender neck which sup-

an astronomical or astrological context, do not

ports the frontally depicted human head whose

have a special astrological connection,20 but reflect

features are no longer identifiable on account of

a general eastern spirit of ʿajāʾ ib, akin to that of

the weathered condition with a prominent three-

the western merveil e, at the mythical creatures of

pronged crown-like headdress The creature’s tail

God’s Creation (al-makhlūqāt) that are thought

curves upward to form a pretzel-like knot termi-

to exist beyond the limits of the known world

nating above the slender wings with curled tip in a

This is expressed in visual hybridisations that

dragon head whose open jaws reveal the protrud-

were particularly pervasive during the twelfth

ing tongue According to the Persian inscription

and thirteenth century in the medieval Central

on the outside lintel the caravanserai was built in

Asian world and beyond

727/1326–7 whereas the Armenian inscription

on the right inside the portal states that it was

constructed six or seven years later by Chesar

c The dragon and the bird

Ōrbēlian and his brothers (fig 67); just like the

türbe of Hüdavend Hatun, the caravanserai was

From ancient times the bird and the serpent

erected during the reign of the last Ilkhanid ruler

represented two of the mightiest cosmic enti-

Abū Saʿīd Baḥādur Khān (r 717/1316–736/1335)

ties Their interaction harks back to well-known

Hence in contrast to the animal combat in

mythic themes recorded from ancient Mesopo-

which the victorious antagonist would assimilate

tamia,21 Greece22 and India 23 In these archaic

some of the essential attributes of the defeated

accounts a bird is identified with the theft of the

animal, the hybrid examples referred to above

elixir of eternal life, whose custodian the serpent

amalgamated not only the form but presum-

would once have been

ably also the nature of the disparate elements,

Early Islamic histories, such as Balʿamī’s

in other words their innate characteristics and

Tarjumat-i tārīkh-i Ṭabarī, record several stories

attributes This fusion was a conspicuous feature

in which the rooster is considered apotropaic In

perhaps intended not only to reinforce the visual

a passage of the chapter on Gayūmart (Av gaya

impact but also to augment the intended effect

marətan “mortal life”), the mythical First Man of

of a potent symbol It has been shown that one

the Mazdean myth of creation, Balʿamī describes

of the most commonly depicted themes is that

him witnessing the scene of a white rooster victo-

of dragon heads issuing from the tails or wing

riously attacking a serpent in the middle of the day

tips of real or imaginary creatures some of which

and then crowing gleeful y Gayūmart thence pro-

may sometimes be identified as one of the con-

nounces the rooster to be an auspicious portent

stellations visualised as one of the twelve signs

The same chapter notes that contrarily a rooster’s

20 Cf Rogers, 1969, pp 154–5 and ns 15 and 16; Badiee,

who held it between chest and neck, twisting backward

1978, pp 255–6

And he dropped it to the ground, hurting with pain,

21 The Babylonian myth of Etana (surviving in Old Baby-

and it fell in the midst of the army while he gave a cry

lonian, Middle Assyrian and Neo-Assyrian recensions) that

and flew off down the wind The Trojans shivered to

contains the fable of the serpent and the Zu bird relates how

see the shining snake (ophis) which lay among them,

both lived in peaceful coexistence, “in the shade of the styrax

a portent from Zeus of the aegis

tree begets the serpent; on its crown begets the eagle” until

one day the eagle treacherously devoured the young of the

Tr after Redfield, 1975, repr 1994, p 144 The motif similarly

serpent and the serpent, in revenge, broke the eagle’s wings

appears in Aristophanes’ Equites 218–22 and in Plutarch’s

and threw him into a deep pit where he was doomed to

Vita Themistocles 26

perish Etana found and healed the eagle who to show his

23 In the Vedic myth recorded in the Rigveda (4 26–7) it

gratitude took him to heaven to bring from there the “plant

is Indra mounted on an eagle or falcon who steals the elixir

of birth” without which Etana could have no offspring See

(Av haoma, Ved sóma) from the atmospheric gandharva s

Knipe, 1967, pp 340–5; also Küster, 1913, pp 52–3, 127–31,

The antagonism between the mythical bird or bird-like crea-

Astour, 1965, p 235, and Reiner, 1991, repr 2003, p 301

ture (often an eagle-like predatory bird), garuḍa, and the

It is of note that the Zu bird represents the evil protagonist

nāga s is a favourite theme in Indian literature which finds

against the the serpent as victim

its origin in the ancient fable of the rival sisters, Kadrū,

22 Homer ( Iliad XII 202–9; see also verse 220) describes

the mother of the nāga s, and Vinatā, the mother of garuḍa,

the battle between eagle and serpent with the words:

recorded in the Mahābhārata ( Ādi-parvan 25–34); Vogel,

1926, pp 51–3 Cf Denis, E , La Lokapaññati et les idées cos-

and a bird came a high-flying eagle holding a

mologiques du Bouddhisme ancien, Paris, 1977, vol 1, 170–1,

huge scarlet snake (drakōn) in its talons, alive still,

as cited by Strong, 1992, pp 200–1, with further examples on

twitching Nor did it give up the fight It struck the one

pp 29, 188–9, 200–8

dragons and animals of the natural and the mythical realms

77

crowing at night was considered an inauspicious

dragon heads, which flank elaborately rendered

sign Its crowing at such an unusual hour served

palmette trees (fig 68) 29

as a warning that saved Siyāmak, Gayūmart’s

Islamic textiles largely survive in relatively

grandson (according to the Bundahishn), from

good condition because they were included in

being attacked by a serpent 24

medieval church treasuries 30 The bird and dragon

Cosmological concepts associating the bird

motif can be found on one such fragment which

with the serpent are recorded in the Meccan tra-

was preserved in the shrine of Saint Apollinaris at

dition, according to which Allāh sent:

the church of Saint Servatius in Siegburg Dragon

from the cupola of heaven a bird in the form of

heads project from spiralling volutes that emerge

an ʿuqāb, a bird with a black back, a white breast

from the outer wing tips of a double-headed bird

and yellow claws While the serpent on the wall

(probably an eagle) with “ears” set within shield-

of the Kaʿba opened its mouth in order to repel

shaped medal ions The expressive crested dragon

the bird, the latter came, caught it by its head

heads are rendered with large, circular eyes and

and took it to the mountain Ajjād 25

particularly wide-open snouts tapering to pointed

Wensinck interprets this tradition as a reference

tips and revealing the tongue (figs 69a and b) 31

to the three cosmological powers, “the sun [sym-

The silk has been attributed by Friedrich Sarre to

bolised] by the bird, the ocean by the serpent, and

an Anatolian manufactory, where it might have

the earth by its navel, the sanctuary [the Kaʿba] ”

served as a Saljuq coronation robe,32 and has been

26

He further notes that the age-old symbolism of:

dated to the first quarter of the thirteenth cen-

tury 33

the eagle with the serpent in its mouth or

Comparable imagery of the double-headed bird

between its talons is a striking illustration of

of prey is preserved in architectural ornamenta-

the idea of cosmic victory … Eagle and serpent

tion at the confines of the same cultural sphere

are the representatives of two of the mightiest

The same bird with “dragon-wings” can also be

cosmic entities, the sun and the ocean 27

found on either side of the western gateway of

yet although birds and (serpent-)dragons are

the thirteenth-century Great Mosque of Divriği

depicted as opposing symbols, the sky and water/

(Diwrīgī), situated on the borders of Armenia

earth, above and below, they are often conjoined

and Cappadocia The dragon heads are rendered

into a composite generated from the same stock

with elongated wide-open mouths emitting curv-

of concepts and images 28 This visual conflation

ing, tongue-like foliage, which in turn extends

of the bird with the dragon can be seen in par-

to the outspread wing tips of the double-headed

ticular on textiles, which due to their portability

birds (figs 70a and b) 34 The mosque was built

and high status, were a prime luxury medium

in 626/1228–9 (or later) by native craftsmen of

for the transmission of a visual vocabulary The

Akhlāt (northwest of Lake Van) for the Türk-

motif is exemplified, for instance, on a twelfth-

men Mengüjükid ruler Aḥmad Shāh and his

or thirteenth-century silk samite fragment from

wife, Tūrān Malik, who were under Saljuq suze -

Samangan province in Afghanistan, of elongated

rainty 35 The epigraphic band above the main

rectangular form, featuring pairs of large and

portal of the mosque mentions the name and

stately confronting birds, probably roosters, with

title of ʿAlāʾ al-Dīn Kay Qubādh, presumably in

prominent combs and florid tails terminating in

recognition of his overlordship 36

24 Recorded in Balʿamī’s Persian translation of Ṭabarī’s

Museum of Art, inv no 1990 2 Watts and Wardwell, 1997,

History; tr and ed Lazard, 1956, pp 206–7, 211

cat no 43

25 Ibn Hishām’s edition of the Ibn Isḥāq’s Sīra, ed Wüsten-

30 Cf Shalem, 2004, pp 125–30

feld, 1857, p 125; al-Diyārbakrī, Ḥusayn ibn Muḥammad,

31 Cf Jacques and Wencker, 1967, pp 472–527 and

Taʾrīkh al-khamīs, vol 1, Cairo, 1283, p 112, cited after Wen-

487–90 A smaller fragment (length 22 5 cm, width 21 cm)

sinck, 1921, repr 1978, p 47 Cf Atallah, 1975, p 164

is preserved in Staatliche Museen Preussischer Kulturbesitz,

26 Wensinck, 1921, repr 1978, p 47

Kunstgewerbemuseum, Berlin, inv no 81 745 The Arts of

27 Idem, p 46

Islam, 1976, p 79, cat no 14; von Wilckens, 1992, p 43, fig

28 The theme of the transformation of a serpent into

66, colour pl on p 48; Gierlichs, 1993, p 30, pl 10, cat no 84

an eagle occurs for instance in the Alexander Romance;

32 Otto-Dorn, 1978–9, p 119

Pseudo-Callisthenes I, ch 10, tr and ed Stoneman, 1991,

33 von Wilckens, 1992, p 43, cat no 66

p 42

34 Otto-Dorn, 1978–9, p 120, fig 18; Enderlein, 1990,

29 Related imagery occurs on a mid-thirteenth-century

p 88; Firat, 1996, no pagination Gierlichs, 1996, pl 3, 1–4

lampas weave which carries addorsed felines and double-

35 Sourdel-Thomine, “Diwrīgī,” EI 2 II, 320a

headed eagles in the interstices grasping curled outer tail

36 Van Berchem, 1910, pp 97–8; Otto-Dorn, 1978–9,

feathers that end in dragon heads; preserved in the Cleveland

p 121

78