The Dragon in Medieval East Christian and Islamic Art by Sara Kuehn, Sebastian Günther, et al - HTML preview

PLEASE NOTE: This is an HTML preview only and some elements such as links or page numbers may be incorrect.
Download the book in PDF, ePub, Kindle for a complete version.

chapter five

to a sacred building where they served to protect

It is interesting to note that the representation of

the building In their function as “guardians” of

the serpent body coiled around the central pole

entrances to sacred places or to “treasures” they

also has an analogy in ancient Hindu mythology,

were endowed with an apotropaic function

in which the body of the great cosmic dragon

Vāsuki (“Possessor of Treasures”) serves as giant

churning rope to rotate Mount Mandara in the

e The dragon and the elephant

wel -known myth of the “Churning of the Ocean”

(Samudramanthana) which produces the nectar

The ingenuity of al-Jazarī was further proven

(amṛta) of divine immortality 73 In the course of

when later in his career he entered the service of

the story, the demons Rāhu and Ketu become

Qutb al-Dīn Suqmān (581/1185–597/1201) and

involved, an episode which is discussed below

began inventing mechanical devices, such as the

in chapter 8

so-cal ed “elephant water-clock ” This water-clock

The motif of the serpent that appears to

was amongst the devices originally compiled and

threaten the birds is based on a related design by

illustrated by al-Jazarī, and is shown on a leaf

an earlier craftsman, acknowledged by al-Jazarī,74

from the Kitāb fī maʿrifat al-ḥiyāl al-handasiyya

the late eighth-century Pseudo-Archimedes,75

which was copied by Muḥammad ibn yūsuf ibn

whose work included frequent representations

ʿUthmān al-Ḥaṣkafī at Diyārbakr, and dated to

of the dragon on clocks, knockers or as spouts

the end of Shaʿbān 602/about 10 April 1206, now

of ewers From this it appears that motifs ulti-

preserved in the Topkapı Sarayı Library in Istan-

mately derived from Hellenistic sources enjoyed

bul (fig 84) “The passage of constant hours,”70

widespread popularity in the medieval Islamic

the concept of the ebb and flow of time and the

world And although he has suggested no sym-

seasons, is indicated by a scale adjusted by a small

bolic meaning for his creations, al-Jazarī may well

person seated atop an elephant passant within a

have taken for granted that his audience was well

tall tower that supports the device Perched on

aware of the overall symbolism, in which case

top of the tall domed tower, a bird spins around

the omission is inconclusive The depictions may

every half an hour, whereupon the elephant driver

therefore have well been part of an apotropaic

strikes his elephant and another figure causes the

and, perhaps, talismanic tradition

falcon to release a pebble In his description of

On textiles of the early medieval period the

the central mechanism al-Jazarī states:

imagery of the elephant, the giant among ani-

transversely between the centres of the pillars

mals, was fairly frequent It has been preserved

is an axle on which are two serpents, the claws

on several Umayyad76 and Byzantine textiles77

of each one grasping the axle, its tail around the

made in imitation of late Sasanian examples 78

axle like a ring, its head tilted backwards, the

In the medieval Islamic period elephants had

mouth open as if to swallow the falcon,71 the

great value and regal status and as such were

edge of the lower lip is touching the front of the

often richly caparisoned 79 Such noble pachy-

castle [the tower], and the upper lip is spread,

derms are shown together with disproportionately

with the two fangs bared 72

diminutive quadruped dragons on a saddle cloth,

provenance and a late twelfth- or early thirteenth-century

77 Grabar, 1951, p 35 Cf the “Elephant Silk” from

date ( L’Etrange et le Merveilleux en terres d’Islam, 2001,

the tomb of Charlemagne, Treasury of Aachen Cathedral

p 232, cat no 160) Paris, Musée du Louvre, Département

(Grabar, 1951, p 35, fig 3); or, an eleventh-century Arme-

des Antiquités orientales, Section Islamique, inv no MOA

nian painting showing king Gagik-Abas of Kars (1029–

97 Rouault and Masetti-Rouault, eds , 1993, cat no 471

1064), sitting in state with his wife and daughter on a low

(colour photograph)

throne covered with a textile decorated with pearl roundels

70 Tr Hill, 1974, p 48

containing elephants (illustration from the Gospel book of

71 Idem, p 59 and 1984, p 238

Gagik-Abas of Kars, perhaps painted in Kars, c 1050 Jeru-

72 Idem, p 68

salem, Armenian cathedral of Saint James, Ms 2556, fol

73 Cf Long, 1976, pp 177–81

135bis Der Nersessian, 1945, p 119, pl XXIII 2; Glory of

74 Kitāb fī maʿrifat al-ḥiyāl al-handasiyya, tr Hill, 1974,

Byzantium, 1997, p 353, photograph to the left); king Gagik

pp 272, 279 and idem, 1998, ch XII, “The Banū Mūsà and

himself is shown to wear a garment with a comparable pat-

their “Book of Ingenious Devices,” p 73; Meinecke, 1996,

tern and a tiraz with Kufic letters at the upper arms, indi-

p 63 and n 27

cating an Islamic origin This led André Grabar to suggest

75 Possibly the work of a late eighth-century Muslim

that the garment may have been a gift by a Muslim sovereign

inventor who based his work on several earlier sources

It moreover shows that this pattern was evidently linked to

including probably Philon and Heron Cf Kitāb fī maʿrifat

both Armenian and Islamic contexts

al-ḥiyāl al-handasiyya, tr Hill, 1974, p 10

78 Grabar, 1951, pp 40–2

76 Jerusalimskaja, 2000, p 114 and n 13

79 Bosworth, 1963, p 117

dragons and animals of the natural and the mythical realms

83

known as the celebrated Khurasanian “Elephant

authors suggest that the dynamic representation

Silk,” which was preserved as the shroud of Saint

of dragons and elephants on the Varakhsha wall

Jodokus (Saint Josse) (fig 85a) 80 The silk samite

paintings may be a translation of the same theme

survives as a group of fragments which show two

onto a textile in a more static manner and without

superimposed pairs of large, confronted ele phants

any apparent connection to the combat theme

in the central field The great beasts are lavishly

portrayed at the Varakhsha wall paintings 84

caparisoned with saddle blankets, their heavy feet

The name of the pachyderm certainly appears

with articulated toes being singled out for empha-

as title and opening verse of the early Meccan sūra

sis These potent symbols of power are each paired

105 of the Qurʾān alluding to the failed expedi-

with a disproportionately tiny quadruped dragon

tion of the yemenite king Abraha against Mecca

with a very long sinuous neck almost disappearing

His troops had been accompanied by an elephant

between its legs The four-legged dragons rest on

which on arriving at the frontier of Meccan ter-

feet with separated toes and long, needle-pointed

ritory, knelt down and refused to advance fur-

talons, their stiffly raised wings terminating in a

ther towards the city The episode is related to

small curled tip following post-Sasanian conven-

the tradition according to which the birth of the

tions, and their raised undulant tails terminating

Prophet is said to have taken place at this time,

in a pointed tuft of hair (fig 85b) 81 The depiction

in the “year of the Elephant ”85

is framed above and below by a Kufic inscrip-

These majestic quadrupeds had a special status

tion in mirror image which includes glory and

and were covetously guarded by the sulṭān s Rulers

good wishes to the owner, Qāʾid Abu ’l-Manṣūr

bestowed elephants only as a great favour or when

Bākh-tigīn, the Turkish āmir of Khurasan, whose

a commander was appointed to a particularly

execution in 349/960–1 by order of his Samanid

responsible post 86 Among the Būyids, ʿAḍud al-

sovereign ʿAbd al-Malik ibn Nūh presents a ter-

Dawla had war elephants (fuyūl muqātila) which

he used against his cousin Bakhtiar ibn Muʿizz

minus ante quem for dating the textile 82 The silk

al-Dawla in 366/977 87 It was also the Ghaznawid

is framed in the style of a carpet by a procession

sulṭān Masʿūd’s favourite mount for hunting 88 On

of camels with flying scarves and roosters with

formal occasions involving solemn processions

beaded neckbands in each of the corners It thus

(mawākeb) the sulṭān rode on an elephant, as in

provides a combination of Sasanian style elements

September 422/1031, when Masʿūd proceeded to

with Central Asian aspects such as the dragons

the plain of Shābahār outside Ghazna to preside

and the camels Belenitskii and Bentowitsch note

over a session of the maẓālim court held for the

analogies in the motifs to Sogdian art, in particu-

redress of wrongs 89 The representation of lav -

lar with the eighth-century wall painting frieze of

ishly caparisoned elephants must therefore have

the Red Hall at the Sogdian palace at Varakhsha,

served as a proclamation of power and authority

northwest of Bukhara, featuring elephants being

for the Turkish āmir Qāʾid Abu ’l-Manṣūr Bākh-

attacked by long-necked mythical creatures 83 The

tigīn The unusual depiction of elephants together

80 The saint whose seventh-century tomb is in Runiacum,

to the second half of the eleventh century and probably exe-

present-day Saint-Josse-sur-Mer, near Pas-de-Calais, Musée

cuted somewhere in the Ani region (yerevan, Matenada-

de Louvre, Paris, inv no 7502; Pope and Ackerman, eds ,

ran Ms 7736, fol 9r); see Gevorkian and Abgarian, eds ,

1938–9, repr 1964–81, vol 6, pl 981; text, vol 3, pp 1928–

1996, pl 54

39 and 2002; Ettinghausen, Grabar and Jenkins-Medina,

82 Combe, Sauvaget and Wiet, eds , 1933, vol 4, no 1507,

1987, repr 2001, p 244, fig 260; von Wilckens, 1991, p 48,

with bibliographical data Cf Ettinghausen, Grabar and

fig 43, and p 347, n 47; technical analysis in Bul etin de liai-

Jenkins-Medina, 1987, repr 2001, p 401, n 66

son du CIETA 33, 1971, pp 22–57 A silk fragment of uncer-

83 Belenitskii, 1980, p 228; Belenitskii and Bentowitsch,

tain date featuring a related elephant pattern is found at

2000, pp 44–5

Siegburg; cf Meredith-Owens, “Fīl,” EI² V, 690b Étienne de

84 Eidem, 2000, p 45

Blois, count of Bologne and commander of the first Crusade,

85 See al-Azraqī, Kitāb Akhbār Makkah, ed Wüstenfeld,

is said to have procured the precious textile together with his

1861, vol 4, German tr , pp 48–9

two brothers Godefroy de Blois and Baudoin, and to have

86 Bosworth, 1963, p 117

offered it to the Abbaye Saint-Josse of which the counts

87 See Christensen, 1944, p 208 Anon , Taʾrīkh-i Sīstān,

were benefactors Cf La France romane, 2005, p 177, cat

ed Bahār, M S , Tehran, 1314/1935, p 206; Miskawayh,

no 124

Tajārib al-umam, tr and ed Margoliouth, 1921, vol 5, p 402

81 It is interesting to note that closely related depictions

88 Bosworth, 1963, p 118

of these unusual, extremely long-necked quadruped dragons

89 Bayhaqī, Taʾrīkh-i Masʿūdī, ed Ghani and Fayyāz,

with their uplifted feathery wings and vertically raised tails are

Tehran, 1324/1945, pp 372–3, as cited in Bosworth, “Court

prominently portrayed flanking a tree-like composition in a

and courtiers: In the Islamic Period to the Mongol Con-

headpiece of the Armenian Gospel book of Mughni, datable

quest,” EIr

84