The Dragon in Medieval East Christian and Islamic Art by Sara Kuehn, Sebastian Günther, et al - HTML preview

PLEASE NOTE: This is an HTML preview only and some elements such as links or page numbers may be incorrect.
Download the book in PDF, ePub, Kindle for a complete version.

chapter six

under his horse’s hooves remained essentially a

shown convincingly that the prostrate figure on

symbol of victory, it also introduced a moral and

these amulets represents a female demon who

spiritual meaning 172

harms children and pregnant women as attested

It is this very motif which provides a link with

by late antique magical sources and that the amu-

the hagiographical iconography of the holy rider

lets served as prophylactic charms against a vari-

vanquishing an enemy which appears on Jewish173

ety of illnesses 178 However, the systematic study

or Christian magical “amulets” that circulated in

of this iconography is complicated by difficul-

the Byzantine world These frequently show on

ties in dating the amulets and by the frequent

the obverse an anonymous rider saint spearing a

absence of legends which would make it possible

prostrate figure, generally represented as female

to identify the equestrian figure The rare accom-

with long hair, who raises her hands in a vain

panying legends invoke Solomon the horseman,

attempt at supplication or defence More rarely

the formidable enemy of demons, and/or Saint

the figure appears to be portrayed with a bare

Sisinnios179 (who is thought to have been a Par-

female torso and what may perhaps be a serpen-

thian),180 permitting identification with either or

tine lower body 174 The choice of a female figure as

both of these figures

the vanquished enemy reflects perhaps the ancient

Through the use of his “magical” seal and other

belief in dangerous female demons which may go

ritual techniques attributed to him, the Jewish

back to the Lilith of Jewish legend 175 Of note is

king Solomon was considered to be the archetypal

that the term Druj,176 the demoness of deceit and

controller of spirits and demons,181 the quintes-

treachery, is applied in later Avestan texts to a

sential warrior-magician, a figure that reflected

whole class of female demons 177 It has also been

a conflation of parallel Jewish, Christian, Greek

172

178

Grabar, 1936, pp 44, 47

Bonner, 1950, pp 210–8; Spier, 1993, pp 25–62,

173 While monotheism and the prohibition of images

esp pp 33–44 For the transmission from early Near Eastern

restrained Jews from developing divine or demonic figural

to Jewish and classical Greek mythology of the belief in a

images, the Second Commandment was not strictly observed

female demon, bringer of harm to children and pregnant

by all Jewish communities Special highlights of Jewish fig-

women, see Barb, 1966, pp 1–23 The aid of Saint Sisinnios

ural art are, for instance, the wall paintings of the third-

is also invoked in Armenian talismanic scrolls against the

century synagogue at Dura Europos (see Rostovtzeff, 1939,

female demon Āl, known throughout the Persian-speaking

p 102) and the mosaics of the sixth-century synagogue of

world, who is believed to be the personification of puerperal

Beth Alpha (Sukenik, 1932)

fever which strikes women in childbed Cf Russell, 2004,

174 For a detailed analysis of this type, see Bonner, 1950,

pp 447–8 On the Āl, see also Goldziher, 1896, vol 1, p 16;

pp 99, 208–21, pls XIV–XVII, nos 294–301, 306, 309, 311,

Winkler, 1931, pp 104–7; and, in particular, the monograph

314, 315, 318, 319, 323–7 Cf Perdrizet, 1903, and idem, 1922;

of Eilers, 1979

179

Peterson, 1926, p 103, 107 (lower illustration); Engemann,

The most elaborate visual representation of the

1975, p 25 and fig 1, p 37 and fig 6, n 111 with references

mounted Saint Sisinnios appears on the seventh- or eighth-

on the so-called seals with Solomon on horseback; Thierry,

century fresco found on the west wall of chapel XVII in the

1999, pp 238–9 and ns 20, drawings 2 a-c; Alexander,

Apa Apollon monastery at Bawīṭ in Upper Egypt where he

1999, pp 1076–1077, fig 32 2 Cf also Bank, A V , Gemma

spears a prostrate female figure identified as the demoness

s izobrazeniem Solomona, Vizantijskij Vremennik 8, Moscow,

“Alabasdria ” Excavated in 1901–2 by Clédat, 1904–6, xii 2,

1956, pp 331–8; as cited in Walter, 1989a, pp 665–6,

pp 79–81; Perdrizet, 1922, pp 13–5; Lewis, 1973, fig 30 (pls

n 57; idem, 2003, fig 14 The reverse of the amulets depict

unnumbered)

180

various scenes, the most common being the representa-

Perdrizet, 1922, p 13; Maguire, 1995, p 57 Peterson

tion of the “all-suffering eye ” The ancient symbol is usually

(1926, p 118) considers the Sisinnios legend to have an

depicted as an eye whose pupil is pierced by various sharp

Iranian origin Rika Gyselen (1995, pp 89–90), moreover,

weapons and attacked by several fierce or noxious animals;

remarks upon the resemblance of the name (and apparent

as portrayed, for instance, at the Dura synagogue (Enge-

function) of Saint Sisinnios and that of the Iranian “mage”

mann, 1975, pp 22–48 and p 27, fig 5; Doro, 1941, pp 220–

Sāsān found on many Sasanian magical seals while excluding

1) Cf Walter, 1989b; Thierry, 1999, p 240 For a recent

the possibility of an inverse influence (on the figure of Sāsān,

study dedicated to Sasanian-period glyptics with this motif

pp 55–6)

181

which however sees the subjects represented on the seals as

Solomon evolved as legendary magician, endowed

having originated in the Mediterranean and the Near Eastern

with exceptional wisdom and believed to be skilled in the art

civilisations, see Magistro, 2000, pp 167–94 For a discus-

of exorcising spirits and demons A detailed description of

sion of Byzantine amulets with a rider saint spearing a pros-

an exorcism is related by the first-century historian Josephus

trate she-demon, see Spier, 1993, pp 25–62, esp pp 60–2,

( Antiquitates Iudaicae 8 45–9) as well as by the late antique

and pl 2, nos a, 15, and b, 21, pl 3, no a, 33 and pl 6,

Testamentum Salomonis, an uncanonical religious text which

no d

appears to be a Christian adaptation of a contemporary

175 Cf Hutter, “Lilith,” DDD, pp 520–1; Bonner, 1950,

demonological Jewish text entirely devoted to Solomon’s

p 210

power over demons (ed from manuscripts at Mount Athos,

176 See, for instance, Bundahishn 2 3 3 23–4; Boyce, 1984,

Bologna, Holkham Hall, Jerusalem, London, Milan, Paris

p 50

and Vienna by McCown, 1922, esp chs 3–18) Cf Bonner,

177 Cf Langton, 1949, p 70; Bonner, 1950, p 210

1950, p 209

the dragon in scenes of combat

105

and Iranian traditions when moreover interest in

individuals as stated by orthodox Zoroastrian-

extraneous doctrines and cults was very active 182

ism),189 as is evidenced by the Qumran texts, early

These visual images of triumph over the enemy

Christianity and all Gnostic religions (Hermeti-

or over the powers of evil were naturally adopted

cism, Gnosticism, Manichaeism) 190 Christianity,

for the presentation of warrior saints,183 the actual

in turn, inherited most of its eschatological per-

systematisation of their cult probably having

spective from the Iranian-inspired apocrypha of

taken place in Constantinople 184 The image of

the Old Testament and the Jewish writings of the

the dragon being trampled by a potent rider’s

period just before its emergence 191

horse, traceable to at least the early seventh cen-

The eschatological concept in the struggle

tury, thus mirrors the symbolic meaning of spiri-

against a dragon in Judaeo-Christian tradition

tual triumph over the persecutions of tyrannical

has close analogies in ancient Iranian texts, cited

pagan rulers, representing the crushing of evil and

above In the Old Testament the resurrection is

Satan through conversion and the destruction of

connected with the myth of Leviathan (Hebrew

pagan temples 185

liwyātān; Ugaritic ltn) who is slain by yahweh and

The close parallels in iconography between

thus plays a role in the eschatological struggle 192

the Iranian and the Judaeo-Christian tradi-

In the Syriac Apocalypse of Baruch (29 4; perhaps

tions expressing the fundamental juxtaposition

early second century ad) Leviathan together with

between victor and vanquished, however, may in

another mythical monster, Behemoth, rises out

large part be due to the influence of Iranian dual-

of the sea at the coming of the Messiah 193 In the

ist notions on the religions of the Near East from

Apocalypse of John (20 1–3) the “old dragon”

the Achaemenid period to the early centuries of

is identified with Satan, evil incarnate An angel

the present era 186 The strong dualistic character

descends from heaven with a key to the abyss,

of Jewish eschatology, including the belief in the

the underworld, and a chain to fetter the dragon

coming of a saviour (messiah),187 a final struggle

there for one thousand years 194 Once this term

between Good and Evil, and the resurrection

has expired, the dragon is freed to take part in the

of the dead, seems also to suggest the strong possi-

great final struggle in which it will be decisively

bility of a borrowing from Zoroastrian doctrine,188

defeated, resulting in the resurrection of the dead

where according to yasna 30 3–5 the good and

and the coming of a new age in which death and

bad spirits were “twins” (separate, independent

evil are no more 195 Almut Hintze concludes:

182 Bonner, 1950, p 18; Alexander, 1999, p 1077; Walter,

(“serpent”) and mashiaḥ (“messiah”), both being equiva-

2003, p 35; Pancaroğlu, 2004, pp 152–3

lent to 358, therefore by the rules of gematria these words

183 Der Nersessian, 1965, p 24

are considered to have a close affinity The idea that the

184 Walter, 1989a, p 663

serpent-messiah would destroy the evil serpent is expressed

185 Especially during and after the exile of the Jews in

in the thirteenth-century writings of Isaac Cohen of Soria

Babylon, Iranian influence may have been instrumental in

in Spain, published by Scholem, 1926, p 273

188

bringing about the change in the conception of Satan from

The main locus of contacts between Jews and

a servant of God (for instance, in Zechariah, 3 1–3 3) to his

Mazdāyasnians was most likely to be Persia and Babylonia

adversary (Duchèsne-Guillemin, “Ahriman,” EIr) At least in

where Jews lived among the predominantly Persian popula-

part a Jewish apocalyptic movement, the early Christian faith

tion; Hintze, 1999, p 78 Cf Shaked, “Eschatology,” EIr

189

inherited a worldview in which Satan played a vital role as

Boyce, 1975, repr 1996, p 193

190

the ultimate adversary or opponent of God and his agents

Shaked, “Eschatology,” EIr; Gnoli, “Dualism,” EIr Cf

In the visions of John, Satan is portrayed as composite beast,

Zaehner, “Zoroastrianism,” CELF, p 159

191

which emerges from the sea (Daniel 7), drawn from the myth

Shaked, “Eschatology,” EIr

192

of a cosmic struggle between a god and a sea monster or

Isaiah 27 1 Heidel, 1942, repr 1951, p 103; Hintze,

dragon informed by a Mesopotamian mythic pattern (cf also

1999, pp 89–90

193

the general discussion in Gunkel, “Die Drachentraditionen,”

Hintze, 1999, pp 80–1 and n 38 Cf 1 Enoch 60 7

1895, pp 29–90, and “die Traditionen vom Urmeer,” 1895,

Related beliefs are found in Gnostic traditions It is interesting

pp 81–111) to which Satan “gave his power and his throne

to consider a later fourteenth-century Samaritan chronicle

and great authority” (Revelation 13 2) This imagery was

which reverts to earlier Jewish, Christian and Samaritan

used in polemical discourses and played an important role

traditions and relates of the first-century Dositheans: “These

in the “demonisation” of either external enemies or internal

people believed that the Serpent will govern the lives of

adversaries of which the Roman imperial power was a

creatures until the day of resurrection ” See Isser, 1976, p 80

194

designated agent

Cf Hintze, 1999, p 81, n 39 with further examples

186

195

Boyce and Grenet, 1991, pp 361–490; Gnoli, “Dual-

Eadem, p 81, and n 41 Cf parallels in the book of

ism,” EIr; Hintze, 1999, pp 72–9, esp pp 75–6

Revelation (20 1–6) where there appears the story of the

187 In connection with the concept of messianism in

leader of the powers of darkness, also referred to as “the

Judaism it is of interest to note the identification of the

dragon, the primeval serpent, which is the devil and Satan,”

saviour and the serpent, which is supported by the numerical

being overpowered and cast into the abyss by an angel who

equivalence of the Hebrew letters of the words naḥash

“sealed it over him, to make sure that he would not deceive

106