The Dragon in Medieval East Christian and Islamic Art by Sara Kuehn, Sebastian Günther, et al - HTML preview

PLEASE NOTE: This is an HTML preview only and some elements such as links or page numbers may be incorrect.
Download the book in PDF, ePub, Kindle for a complete version.

chapter seven

ing up serpent staffs with the process of firemak-

reads as Robes of Light) lost by Adam and Eve

ing 47 yet the figure grasping staffs entwined with

at the Fall but regained through baptism which

serpents and topped by birds or stellar symbols

is understood eschatologically as re-entry into

could indeed represent a mythical giant holding

Paradise 53 Hence the scene may be understood as

what might perhaps represent abbreviated visual

depicting the robed Adam not only as ruler over

formulae of a vegetal motif characterised as the

the world54 but as an image of one who through

“Tree of Life” with serpent motif 48

Christ has discovered the state of divine wisdom

This interpretation gains weight through a

and glory 55

depiction on a floor mosaic discovered in the nave

In sum, it may be noted that Adam, the first

of a church at Huarte, located fifteen kilometres

of men of the biblical creation myth, is repre-

north of Apamea in present-day Syria, and dated

sented just like Gayūmart, the mythical first

by inscription to the years 472 or 487 49 On the

man of the Mazdean creation myth, between

central axis of the pavement close to the sanctu-

two slender elongated plants around which coil

ary is the large frontally rendered figure of Adam,

serpents whose heads are oriented towards the

identified by an inscription above his head He

central figure On the late fifth-century Huarte

is portrayed as fully clothed and enthroned on a

mosaic the association of the cedars in the para-

backless raised platform, leaning against a cush-

disical setting with the Tree of Life is apparent,

ion, and holding an open book in his left hand,

whereas on the seventh-century stamp seals the

while extending the fingers of his right hand in

staff-like motifs may presumably represent abbre-

a gesture of speech Importantly, he is framed by

viated visual formulae; the addition of the birds

two slender cypress trees around each of which is

or stellar symbols at the apex of these verticals

coiled a serpent, its head oriented towards Adam’s

give further substance to this interpretation 56 It

head, the open jaws revealing bifid tongues Adam

may thus be postulated that both depictions por-

is surrounded by a variety of tame beasts and birds

tray a central figure flanked on either side by a

set amidst flowering vegetation indicating that

serpent-entwined Tree of Life motif Ackerman

the setting is the primordial Paradise before the

has moreover noted an astronomical association

Fall (fig 117) 50 Since the image does not accord

for the imagery on the stamp seals 57

with the book of Genesis – Adam being repre-

The conventional medieval Islamic represen-

sented not naked but clothed, enthroned and

tation of rulership features enthroned figures

reading a book – Henry Maguire has proposed

flanked by dragon-headed or dragon-entwined

reading this paradisical scene not in a literal but

staffs; the iconography occurring predomi-

a spiritual sense as allegory 51 Precedent for such

nantly on mid-eleventh to thirteenth-century

an interpretation is found in the notion of the

silver-inlaid metalwork produced in the greater

Robe of Glory, which is commonly found in the

Khurasan region (figs 113–116) Since these are

writings of the early Syriac fathers and ultimately

often framed by a disc with pointed rays, Eva

derives from early Jewish sources 52 The imagery

Baer has interpreted them as artistic formulae of

is repeatedly used in the hymns of the fourth-

princely or royal images transposed in a sense to

century Syriac writer Ephrem, deacon in Edessa

a cosmic setting, and as emblematised luminaries,

and Nisibis, who equates the white robes of those

or panegyrical visual expressions of the “heav-

baptised with the Robes of Glory (which he also

enly ruler,” which sometimes have an astrological

47 Wenzel, 2005, pp 140–58

52 Ephraem, Hymni de Paradiso and Section 2 of

48 For the imagery of the “Tree of Life,” see also the dis-

Commnetarium in Genesium, tr and ed Brook, 1990, pp 31,

cussion in chapter 9, part a It may be notable to repeat here

67, 226–7

James L Sauvé’s view (1970, p 181) on this time-honored

53 Idem, pp 31, 66–74, 94, 112, 226–7

symbol: “Indo-European mythology is a pan-cultural Eur-

54 “God said…have dominion…over every living thing

asian phenomenon, and those studies that overlook the ‘tree

that moveth upon the earth…” (Genesis 1:28) In the Chris-

of life,’ or dismiss it as marginal or incidental in importance,

tian Syriac Meʿārath gazzē 2 11–25 (Cave of Treasures, tr and

must fail to evaluate properly, or even approximately, many

ed Budge, 1927, p 34) God gave Adam power over all beings

aspects of some Indo-European religions and mytholo -

55 Maguire, 1987, p 368, n 23, and p 372, ns 34, 38 In

gies ”

post-exilic Judaism, Midrash and Judeaeo-Christian tradi-

49 Canivet, M T and P , 1975, pp 49–70; Maguire, 1987,

tion the figure of the enthroned Adam is seen as the source

p 367

of supernatural wisdom, see Fodor, 1976, pp 166–7

50 Canivet, M T and P , 1975, p 61 and fig 3; Maguire,

56 Of note may be the parallel given by the Greek poet

1987, p 367 For similar motifs of a tree and serpent with an

Pindar of the drakōn Typhon who supports the column of

enthroned ruler or king, see Fodor, 1976, pp 159–60

the Etna on which perches the eagle of Zeus ( Pythian Odes 1)

51 Maguire, 1987, p 368

57 Ackerman, 1936, p 127

the dragon in relation to royal or heroic figures

117

character 58 An anecdote attesting to the astral

ciation which transposes the motif to a cosmic set-

qualities of the ruler in the face of the dragon is

ting – sometimes with an astrological character

noted by Ibn Bībī, the Rūm Saljuq chronicler, in

The pivotal role the dragon plays in these

which he metaphorically likens the meeting of

images will be further elucidated in the following,

the armies of the Khwārazm-shāh and the Rūm

concluding in a discussion of the time-honoured

Saljuqs to the day on which:

symbolism of the dragon-tamer

… in accordance to servile custom the King of the

Planets kissed the earth at the door of the King

Issuing and devouring

of the World and the encounter of the troops of

the War-Dragon unfurled the crimson and yel ow

The iconography of a human figure, sometimes

banner at the arena of the horizons 59

reduced to the image of a mask-like face, flanked

Luminary imagery is similarly used to describe

on either side by dragons, was one of “great sym-

the birth of Khurshīd shāh in one of the earli-

bolic potency” in the Central Asian world and

est Persian popular romances, the Kitāb-i Samak

beyond and existed in manifold variations 63 The

ʿAyyār, who throughout the story is portrayed

monsters not only frame the central motif but on

in terms of solar metaphors and is even named

account of their gaping jaws at first sight appear to

“king Sun ”60

threaten or perhaps even attempt to devour what

In sum, it may be stated that the visual tradition

they flank The possibility of the latter interpre-

of the medieval Islamic representation of rulership

tation will be discussed in the light of surviving

involves the imagery of a central figure flanked by

examples of this enigmatic imagery

serpent-dragons that top or twine around verti-

The motif is prominently recorded in the visual

cals which might carry a vegetal association that

arts of the Caucasus region, for instance on the

could distantly associate them with the Tree of

Armenian cathedral of the Holy Apostles in

Life motif as ultimate prototype Frequently the

present-day Kars erected by king Abas I between

vertical is shown only with a projecting dragon

930 and 943 in the adjacent secondary Bagratid

head This may thus present yet another example

kingdom of Vanand, near the border with eastern

of the visual conflation that was so pervasive in

Anatolia On the exterior of the drum above the

the medieval Central Asian world and beyond

blind arcades twelve ful -length figures are carved

It would be an example of a visual development

in low relief that in folk tradition are associated

that merges the figure of the dragon with that of

with the twelve apostles The figures have mask-

the staff in a unified whole The Tree of Life motif

like faces and are clad in long robes In what is

exhibited a remarkable persistence and popularity

perhaps a unique occurrence, some are shown to

in Near Eastern and Indo-European61 iconogra-

raise their bent arms upwards, others place their

phy which, as has been discussed above, could

hands on their chests, in what may have repre-

still be gauged in visual and textual sources of the

sented ritually significant gestures and may have

eleventh to thirteenth century, the period when

conveyed a canonical koiné 64 It is conceivable that

this imagery was employed with great regularity 62

the sequence of the movements played a role and

This supports the hypothesis that the prototype of

even al uded to a visual narrative 65 One of the fig-

the vertical may be sought in a vegetal composi-

ures is flanked by a tree-like vegetal composition 66

tion It is moreover notable that the central figure

Next to it is a figure with a looped serpent rising

often grasps with one or two hands the verticals

up at either side of his upper body, the heads

just below the point from which the dragon heads

oriented towards his ears Significantly, the figure

project To this may be added the luminary asso-

does not extend his arms towards the serpents but

58 Baer, 1981, p 14, and eadem, 1983, pp 259–68, 274

far into the shadow used to depict the death of Iskandar

See also the discussion on the astral transformation of the

( idem, vol 4, p 255, l 1849)

Sasanian throne in L’Orange, 1953, pp 37–47

63 Cf Russell, 2004, p 1169

59 Al-Awāmir al-ʿalāʾiyya, tr Duda, 1959, p 170

64 The folding of the arms was a deferential gesture

60 Gaillard, 1987, pp 124–5

known in the Iranised world since Zoroastrianism and was

61 Cf Janda, 2010, pp 320–2

used by Christians in prayer towards God; see Russell, 2004,

62 See also the close association of the tree with the Ira-

p 310 Cf Colledge, 1986, p 16

nian king in the Shāh-nāma account, for instance, the simile

65 For a line drawing of all twelve figures, see Thierry,

of the drying leaves of the tree of the Kayānids employed to

1978, p 47, fig 26

describe the death of Farīdūn (tr and ed Mohl, 1838–1878,

66 Idem, pl V 3

vol 1, p 209, ll 1128–129) or of the noble tree that stretches

118