Early Years and First Call to Ministry
I am an only child. This may account for the fact that I do tend to be somewhat self-centred and self-opinionated although I hope that I do not present myself as arrogant. I would not, in all honesty, describe myself as a natural team player. People who know me, and are well-disposed towards me, will probably say that I have always been quite an independent thinker. Those who are less well-disposed may consider me to be somewhat of a maverick or perhaps even a loose cannon. I certainly have the reputation across the board for being unpredictable and for often surprising people by what I do and say. My own mother said of me that I was a “dark horse” and she was never entirely sure what I was thinking. When I was a child, she used to claim that she could read me like a book. The truth is that she and I both knew that this was completely untrue. As an adult, I have sometimes irritated people by my inscrutability.
So, although I have a very long connection with the mainstream evangelical tradition in the Church of Scotland, I have never been one who blindly follows any one party line. In Kirk politics, I have often taken a pragmatic approach, which some colleagues, at times, have found both puzzling and frustrating.
I first saw the light of day in Aberdeen during World War II. In fact, I was born on 20 April 1943, the day before the worst air-raid to hit that city. At the time, my parents were resident in Peterhead (Aberdeenshire) and my father was Principal Classics Master at Peterhead Academy. I still consider myself to be a “Peterhead loon” and have a great affection for that charming, if somewhat chilly, little town.
Not surprisingly, people can see in me some similarities to both of my parents. However, I am not obviously like either of them. In particular, I do not seem to have inherited many of their respective abilities and talents.
My father, Charles Gordon, was somewhat of an intellectual and had about him the touch of a Renaissance man. He did not have an easy young life. His mother, a strong, stable and resourceful lady, died when he was a young teenager. His father had been invalided out of the First World War. Charles very much had to make his own way in the world. After mopping up many school prizes at Robert Gordon’s College in Aberdeen (where he was a scholarship boy), he managed to clock up two First Class Honours degrees in different subject areas when such awards were much rarer than they are now. He was a brilliant linguist. Although on paper he only had schoolboy French, he was often complimented (by French people) on his elegant and accurate written French prose.
Dad had a lifelong interest in cryptic crossword puzzles which would have left most people standing. Even in his last illness and only days away from death, he was still solving the Sunday Times “Mephisto” puzzle!
Yet, although most people thought of him as a linguist, he also had a lifelong interest in Mathematics. During the time that he was Rector of Dunfermline High School, if a member of the Maths department was absent, he would willingly step in and teach such areas as calculus, trigonometry and solve complicated algebraic equations. I have often thought that, with his unique insights and knowledge, he would have made a good code breaker. After he retired, one of his neighbours was a lecturer in mediaeval French at Aberdeen University. He used to often bring in texts of documents written in obscure and archaic French mixed up with smatterings of Latin. Dad could almost invariably decipher them.
After his death, I made a point of depositing his personal papers, writings and other items, such as his University Greek medal, to Aberdeen University Library archives for preservation. I am glad that I took that simple step. Too much of our social history finishes up on the skip.
In spite of his academic achievements, Charles was always modest and unpretentious. He carried his learning very lightly. Whilst some people have unfavourably compared me with him on an intellectual basis, he himself never once made such an unfair comparison. He had no wish for me to be a carbon copy of him, simply to be true to myself. I do readily admit that I am not half the man that he was.
In 1968, at age 60, Charles retired from Dunfermline High School, after a 20 year tenure and took up a post of Research Lecturer at Moray House College of Education. This was with a view to researching and delivering training to head teachers and potential head teachers on efficient methods of school timetabling. This was an area on which Charles had established himself as quite an expert and perhaps it was something that particularly appealed to his mathematical leanings. There were no computer programmes available in those days. He was virtually “head-hunted” by Dr Douglas McIntosh, formerly Director of Education for Fife who had just taken up the post of Principal of Moray House. Charles was somewhat surprised at the invitation as his relationship with Dr McIntosh over the years had not always run entirely smoothly.
In due course the need for the service grew and Charles became Director of the new Timetabling Advisory Service at Moray House, travelling all of the country, from the South West to the Shetland Islands, presenting seminars and also attempting to rescue despairing head teachers.
For a period of about 18 months, he also served as an Advisor in Education to the Irish Government, an appointment that has always had about it an element of mystery. Charles never knew why he had been invited to take up this role. He enjoyed his trips to Eire and especially his repartee with some of the teaching nuns!
Charles was even more surprised – and somewhat amused – to discover that a street in Dunfermline, near to the High School, had been named “Gordon Terrace” in his honour, shortly after he retired.
Charles had always been careful not to align himself politically. West Fife, at that time, was staunchly Labour and I suspect that if Charles had been prepared, even half-heartedly, to wave the Red Flag, certain honours might well have come his way. The only honour he actually received was the award of a Fellowship by the Education Institute of Scotland (with whom he had a long and somewhat ambivalent relationship) for “signal services to Scottish Education.”
I remember that Charles used to maintain staunchly that he would never agree to serve on a local authority education committee after he retired. Throughout all of his teaching life, he had been an apologist for the position that there should be teacher representation on these committees. Only a few months after his move to Aberdeen in 1968, he was co-opted on to Aberdeen County Council Education Committee, where he served happily for many years. Never say never!
My mother (Gena) was much more artistic. She came from a family for whom music was very important. Gena was a brilliant pianist (LRAM in pianoforte), a competent organist, a good singer and she could turn her hand easily to drawing, painting, embroidery, cooking, baking and such like. How far, if at all, I have inherited any of my parents’ talents and attributes, other must judge. I was always close to both of my parents and still miss them.
I have been connected with the Church of Scotland for just about as long as I can remember. My parents were both “Kirk” people. My father was an elder for most of his adult life. As a schoolboy and as a student, he had attended Torry United Free Church in Aberdeen, where the father of his best friend, John Guthrie (later Church of Scotland minister at Cullen), was minister. Torry UF was then, as now, a staunchly evangelical congregation. My mother was brought up in church culture as her father (my grandfather) was an enthusiastic and committed church organist in Peterhead from the age of 18 to the age of 80.
My own earliest recollection of church was being taken to an infant Sunday school in Bridge Street Church in Wick sometime around 1945. At the time, my father had recently been appointed Rector of Wick High School.
Throughout my childhood and my teenage years, God was very real to me and I do not recollect having any particular problems of doubt. This means that I cannot point to a great “conversion” moment in my life when, as it were, I saw the light. I cannot really remember a time when I hadn’t seen it although, like many people, I have blown hot and cold over the years.
In 1948, when I was aged five, our family moved from Caithness to West Fife, after my father had been appointed Rector of Dunfermline High School. It was a huge culture shock for me. Apart from Sunday school, I had never really interacted with other children before. People in Caithness speak quietly and avoid eye contact, whereas in West Fife people tend to be rather loud-mouthed and “in your face”. It seemed to me that everyone was shouting. I found this scary and I can only describe my first day at Canmore primary school in Dunfermline as among the worst days of my entire life. Fortunately, I did settle down surprisingly quickly. Children are much tougher and more resilient than we sometimes imagine.
Primary school was happy enough for me. It was a very different world and school was certainly low-tech. In the infant class, we were still often using slates and the building was illuminated by gas. Paper was in short supply in these somewhat austere post-war years. Sweets were also strictly rationed and I believe that did me no harm whatsoever. Kids of my vintage were quite fit and well enough fed. There were very few obese children (I doubt if there were any in my school) nor did we seem to be affected by the various allergies that seem to dog so many children today. The great fear at that time was contracting polio, fortunately now a thing of the past in the UK.
I doubt if any of my former teachers would have described me as in any way troublesome. I was a quiet child and basically did as I was told. I managed to keep myself out of scrapes. I remember when I was aged around nine, a rather rough boy tried to pick a fight with me in the playground. I punched him so hard that I sent him flying. I am not proud of doing so but it did demonstrate to my contemporaries that, even if I was quiet and solitary, I was not going to allow myself to be bullied.
I remember very vividly the early 1950s with the unfolding of various important events – the Festival of Britain, the death of King George VI, the conquest of Everest and, of course, the Coronation in 1953. In those times, the general feeling was optimistic and forward looking. Rationing had recently come to an end and people were moving into new modern houses with proper bathrooms and kitchens. Our primary school was wired for electricity for the first time. Parents and staff raised sufficient funds to provide a school radio system. There was still a real sense of community and moving forward to better things. This contrasts with today, where so many people seem to be highly individualistic, competitive, cynical, disillusioned or angry.
At the time of the Coronation, there were some popular songs surrounding the event. One of these began with the words “Elizabeth of England…” When we were learning it in class, I sat silent with my arms folded. The teacher stopped playing the piano and asked me why I was not singing. I replied politely but also assertively, that the Queen was not just the Queen of England, that she was Queen of Scotland too and so it wasn’t fair! The teacher gave me the strangest look – a mixture of smile and frown. Anyway, nothing further was said on this subject and I always remained silent thereafter at any class renderings of this trivial ditty. Once again, I had demonstrated my unpredictability! I also learned something of the power of passive resistance and standing my own ground.
Not long after this event, when I was aged ten, I contracted viral pneumonia. This is the only time in my life to date when I have been seriously ill. The doctor was in a state of considerable anxiety as he had lost a strong young farmer to the same virus only the week before. Antibiotics were of no use as it was a virus. I was comatose and withdrawn. I sensed something was wrong because of my parents’ forced jollity and their whispering with the doctor outside my bedroom door. Children may be small, but they are not stupid. The doctor was visiting me up to three times a day, although unable to do anything of consequence. I thought that there was at least a possibility that I was going to die. In fact, I asked my mother if I was going to die and her immediate laughing refutation of such an idea was totally unconvincing.
I wasn’t really afraid because I did actually believe, with a simple and childlike faith, that Jesus would take me to heaven. I was a bit worried, however, as to how I was going to manage without my Mum and Dad to look after me. I did not realise at the time how difficult it must have been for them to face the real prospect of losing their wee boy, especially an only child. In any event, the crisis passed, I made a full recovery and have enjoyed remarkably robust health throughout my adult life. This is something that I do not take for granted and hope that I never will. We can never know what lies ahead of us.
During our twenty year stay in Dunfermline I went to Sunday school at Dunfermline Abbey and, as a young man, I became actively involved in the life of Erskine Church which was, at the time, located in the centre of the town.{1} This congregation subsequently moved out of the town centre and relocated in a residential area. On my last visit to Dunfermline in 2013, I was sorry to see my old church boarded up and derelict although I believe there are plans to convert the building to community use.
In my early teens, I was certainly affected by the “Tell Scotland” movement and the visits of Dr Billy Graham. Dr Graham made a particular point of working with local churches throughout Scotland. It was a time of real refreshing and renewal and its effects were long lasting. Even people who were not card-carrying evangelicals surprised themselves by being caught up in the momentum, just as had happened in the previous century with the revivals led by Moody and Sankey.
There was, at the time, a young doctor in Dunfermline who had a severe drink problem. He was on the verge of losing his career, livelihood and family. In those days, the police were able to turn an occasional blind eye to drink driving in a way that certainly could not be tolerated today. However, he was on his last warning. Without telling anyone, the doctor in question went to the Billy Graham Crusade in Glasgow and “went forward” in the Kelvin Hall. He experienced a remarkable healing and never touched a drop of alcohol again. In typical Scottish understatement, people in Dunfermline remarked that there must be something in this religion stuff, right enough!
In my mid-teens, partly as a result of visiting Oberammergau on a school holiday in 1959, I seriously thought about converting to Roman Catholicism. I loved the ritual and order as well as the more mystical aspects. I was also very much aware that for Catholic people, their religion seemed to make them happy, whereas the opposite often seemed to apply in Presbyterianism! As this was before Vatican II, the Mass was still being said in magisterial Latin, which aesthetically greatly appealed to me, although I make no pretensions to being a classical scholar. Anyway, the Roman Catholic Church had a narrow escape in that this adolescent phase soon passed and I returned to the fold of the Kirk.
Both as a child and as a teenager, I was somewhat of a mystic and a day-dreamer. (I probably still am.) I was often, it seemed, somewhere else. I generally preferred my own company to that of my peers. Even now, although I can be reasonably outgoing and friendly, I still value a certain degree of solitude.
My parents were concerned that I was spending too much time on my own. They felt that I would benefit from the company of young people of my own age. I was sent to join first the Cubs and then the Scouts. I think it was good for me and in many ways I enjoyed it. I did not much care for the annual camps with their rain-sodden tents, terrible food and unspeakable sanitary arrangements. However, in those days such conditions would have been considered by our parents as character forming. Maybe they were. At a later date, I was connected with the Boy’s Brigade, an organisation for which I also have considerable respect. For a minister, dual nationality can sometimes come in handy when it comes to organisations!
At school, I was very interested in religious studies. In my time, the exams for the Higher Leaving Certificate were held just before the Easter holidays. This left us with a summer term that was filled with interesting (and non-examinable!) activities and projects. I chose as a religious studies project to go “In search of Saint Serf”, a Celtic Saint, known as the Apostle of the Ochils. I cycled for miles over several Saturdays, accompanied by a long-suffering school friend (whose daughter, Rev MaryAnn Rennie, is now the Minister of Dunfermline Abbey).
We were very fortunate at Dunfermline High School in having a specialist teacher in Divinity, Rev Edwin S Towill, an Anglo-Scot who came originally from Carlisle and had enjoyed a very successful parish ministry in Edinburgh. He had a remarkable understanding and tolerance of teenagers, whilst at the same time establishing and maintaining appropriate boundaries. He had his own unique way of opening up religious debate and making people think. He also had a wide knowledge of church history and understood its many traditions.
He was one of the few people whom I have met who could actually be “all things to all men” and yet maintain his own position and integrity. He seemed to be equally comfortable preaching in Dunfermline Abbey as in the local Baptist church where he was an established favourite. I think he taught me to see that it is important to know what you believe and why you believe – but equally important to understand why others sometimes take a different position – and to be able to respect that tradition. Mr Towill did a great deal to foster my own self-esteem and I owe him a considerable personal debt. It is with regret that I say now that I don’t think I ever thanked him properly.
In my sixth year at school, with Mr Towill’s encouragement, I wrote a booklet entitled “Lochore and Ballingry – A Parish History” {2} which was also serialised in the local newspaper, “The Dunfermline Press”. My teachers and peers expressed considerable surprise. Teenage schoolboys do not generally write articles for newspapers. I was told (neither for the first time, nor for the last time) that I was a “dark horse”. The articles gained me the school Divinity prize, one of the very few prizes that I have ever won throughout my entire life.
I was very well behaved at Dunfermline High School, although by no means academically distinguished. As my father was Rector of Dunfermline High School, I maintained a low profile throughout my time there. Some fellow pupils and teachers were a little wary of me, fearing that I might tell tales out of school. I never did, nor would my father have dreamt of putting me into such an invidious position. Nevertheless, my experience at school did tend to foster my existing tendency to be somewhat solitary.
I was told in later life that, both at primary and secondary school level, I enjoyed the reputation among my teachers as being the one pupil in the class who was most likely to ask a really awkward question. Some people might say that I have not greatly changed in that respect.
At school, I absolutely hated games and gymnastics, I suppose largely because I am not a natural team player. I was fortunate in that my gym teacher at school was very understanding and did not force me. I was allowed to go running or swimming on my own or with one or two pals to count as the equivalent of a gym period. I still have no interest in any kind of sport, either as a participant or a spectator. I have only once in my entire life been to a football match and really could not understand why hundreds of people were getting so excited over a few men in ridiculous shorts kicking a bag of wind round a field. However, I am well aware that this is very much a minority view!
During my later years at school, I attempted, with limited success, to foster an interest in music, hoping that I might have inherited some of the talent that was on my mother’s side of the family. I even went to a music camp that was organised for older school kids by Fife County Council. This took place during the Easter holidays, based in Abington, South Lanarkshire in what had been a prisoner of war camp. It was as though little had changed. The dormitory huts were cold and there were few decent washing facilities. The food was sparse and everything seems to be watered down. This was not the kind of grub that teenage boys enjoy. My generation, being wartime babies, had been brought up not to turn up our noses at any food, but I think this was the worst I have ever endured. However, occasionally we were given a Scotch pie which even the camp school kitchen staff could not water down. These were like manna from heaven and even today, the sight of a Scotch pie brings a smile to my face.
I also have had a great interest in hypnosis and altered states of reality since I was a schoolboy. I see no problem with hypnosis being used in Christian circles although some people will rush to condemn it, usually out of ignorance and prejudice. I also see great value in the responsible use of Christian meditation. I am interested to see the increasing use of Mindfulness in a Christian context, even though its origins are not specifically Christian. To me, the earth is the Lord’s and the fullness thereof.{3} It may seem odd for someone who is known to be in the evangelical tradition of the Church of Scotland to be somewhat of a mystic. I am sorry if I don’t fit the template. As I have already said, I do not always tow any party line. I was ordained as an elder of the Church of Scotland in Erskine Church, Dunfermline at the tender age of 21, which, in retrospect, was probably far too young.
After leaving school I read for a degree in law (LL.B) at Edinburgh University. It was actually considerably easier at that time to get into the Law Faculty than into Arts, provided the applicant had a pass in Latin. I note with some amusement that when I applied for admission to the Law Faculty, my application was accepted by return of post even with my minimal entrance group. Those were the days! There was, however, a high drop-out rate at the end of the first year. I was greatly relieved and pleasantly surprised not to be among that number.
In the early 1960s, only some ten per cent of young people went on to University. We Scottish students all got our fees paid (by memory the fees for the whole year amounted to around £35) plus an allowance from the Scottish Education Department. Even students from well-off homes received a minimum maintenance grant of £50 per year, worth very much more then than now. There was no anxiety about finding employment after graduation as there were more jobs available than people to fill them. Life was simpler and, relatively speaking, cheaper. We did not have computers, tablets or smart-phones. Students did not leave University with huge debts as some have to today. Indeed, in those days, nobody wanted to lend money to students. We were expected to be impecunious and, by and large, that is exactly what we were.
I enjoyed the Law course well enough, although my heart was not entirely in it. I probably studied harder than I needed to as I still had rather low self-esteem when it came to academic matters and did not consider myself particularly bright. At school, as I have indicated, I had not been the sharpest knife in the box. I was surprised to find that I was passing the law exams quite comfortably even although the pass mark was 66%. I made some friends at the time and went around with a crowd of pleasant young men, with all of whom, sad to say, I have now lost touch.
I well remember my graduation day in the McEwen Hall in Edinburgh in 1964 not long after my 21st birthday. In fact, I had what would now be called an “aha” moment. I had always assumed that if anyone went to University s/he would emerge at the other end knowing a great deal. Actually, I somewhat ruefully realised that although I had managed to pass a lot of tiresome exams, I had forgotten most of what I had swotted up and that I probably did not know very much that was actually worth knowing. This was a very significant discovery for me. I believe true wisdom often lies in being aware of what we do not know. Whilst I do value the privilege of a University education, I realise that it is not the “be all and end all” of everything. The most important lessons of life are not taught there or indeed in any place of learning.
After graduation, I served the traditional two year law apprenticeship with an Edinburgh firm of solicitors. It was a useful experience in some ways although my heart was even less in legal practice than it had been in legal study. It was a useful discipline in learning how to get things done. I did, however, enjoy conveyancing, which had been my strongest subject at University. I remember spending more time than I really needed, in Robert Adam’s handsome search room at HM Register House at the end of Princes Street pouring over copies of (mainly) Victorian feu charters.
During that time, I also continued my local church commitments and served for a time as Clerk to the Trustees and Managers of Erskine Church, Dunfermline. As the name might suggest to those who are au fait with Scottish church history, this was a former UP congregation which maintained a strict demarcation between the spiritual (Kirk Session) and the secular (Managers) leadership of the church. Even at that time, the minister did not attend meetings of the Managers.
I was also quite a popular speaker at various societies in Dunfermline and especially around Burns Night times. On one occasion, when only in my fifth year at school, I had suddenly stepped in to recite “Tam O’ Shanter” at a local Burns Supper, taking the place of my Dad, who was a Burns enthusiast, but had developed a sore throat. Whilst I did not think then – nor do I think now – that I do it as well as he did, I still occasionally enjoy reciting this entertaining poem. Indeed, I have always rather enjoyed public speaking, in spite of being quite reserved in private conversation. I suppose it is fair comment to say that most ministers and teachers do quite like the sound of their own voices? Enough said!
It was during my time as a Law Apprentice that I decided to test my growing sense of a call to the ministry of the Church of Scotland. For the first time in my adult life, I felt really thrilled and excited. My destiny was calling me. My life’s work was beginning to open up before me; or so it seemed.
Climbing the Mound
Not surprisingly, there were a number of formalities to go through in order to be recognised as a candidate for the ministry. I had to complete the inevitable application form and supply appropriate references. In those far-off days, the selection process for ministry candidates was surprisingly light and uncomplicated compared with today. I was simply invited to attend for an afternoon interview in the Church of Scotland Offices at 121 George Street in Edinburgh. On the basis of the interview, and furnishing suitable references, the decision would be made.
So, I duly presented myself in my uncomfortable best suit and white shirt before a roomful of the great and the good. In those days, they were all men, of course, and comprised a selection of senior ministers and elders plus a number of academics, who (perfectly graciously) grilled me for the best part of an hour.
One member of the panel was Professor Norman Porteous, the Principal of New College, whom I liked immediately and whom I would come to know much better at a later date. Though he looked somewhat austere and scholarly, he had a twinkle in his eye and gave me the impression of someone who was able to carry his considerable scholarship surprisingly lightly.
Professor Porteous encouraged me – in fact, virtually instructed me there and then – to sit the New College Bursary Competition. When I said I did not think I was of sufficient academic calibre, he told me quite firmly not to put myself down and that the Faculty of Divinity took a very kind view of anyone who attempted the Competition. To cut a long story short, I did attempt it. Part of the exercise involved writing screeds of essay questions on theological subjects about which I knew next to nothing. Being self-opinionated, this was not such a major challenge as I had anticipated! I am not someone who is generally short of words, although I readily confess that I can certainly be short on depth and content!
I came in fifth in order of merit out of six candidates and was awarded the Buchanan Bursary of just over £40 a year, which certainly bought a very great deal more in 1966 than it would today. Twice a year, I had to venture into the marble splendour of the Head Office of the Bank of Scotland on the Mound to collect my “moiety”. This extra money proved to be extremely welcome over my three years of study. Once again, I was also fortunate enough to have my University fees paid and I was awarded a maintenance grant by the Scottish Education Department. I also appreciated the small salaries that were paid to me in the course of my three student assistantships.
There duly came my formal acceptance from the Church of Scotland as a candidate in training for the ministry plus the required endorsement by my (then) home Presbytery of Dunfermline and Kinross.
Before entering New College, I also had to attempt to master the elements of New Testament Greek in my spare time and pass a prescribed exam. I had studied a little (and I mean “a little”) classical Greek at school before dropping the subject like a hot brick, so at least I knew the Greek alphabet, if nothing else. In spite of some anxiety, I did manage to pass the exam comfortably and, to my great surprise, New Testament Greek actually became one of my strongest subjects. I do sometimes surprise myself, as well as other people.
We were also required to sit a pre-entry exam, set on behalf of the Church of Scotland, on certain books of the Bible. So, even before I arrived at New College, I felt that I had been well and truly examined and, to my great relief, had passed muster.
There were also Church of Scotland exams on the English Bible at the beginning of our second and third years of study. Even today, many people seem to assume that th