The Dragon in Medieval East Christian and Islamic Art by Sara Kuehn, Sebastian Günther, et al - HTML preview

PLEASE NOTE: This is an HTML preview only and some elements such as links or page numbers may be incorrect.
Download the book in PDF, ePub, Kindle for a complete version.

chapter eight

tions to northwest India 85 In his Kitāb al-Tafhīm

figure is shown to hold either a pair of upright

li-awāʾil ṣināʿat al-tanjīm (“Book of Instruction

dragons, their bodies forming a loop,92 or vertical

in the Elements of the Art of Astrology”), writ-

staffs (figs 113–116); both the coiling bodies and

ten upon his return to Ghazna in 422/1031, he

the allegorical staffs end in confronted dragon

refers to the two fictitious nodes, the eighth

heads with gaping snouts It is significant that rep-

and a ninth planet, as knot (ʿuqda) and point of

resentations of the planet jawzahar thereby make

crossing (majāz) 86 In spite of his statement that

use of the emblematic portrayal of the cosmic

“they are not real planets,” the same author does

ruler mentioned earlier, framed by dragon-headed

however record the position of the raʾs al-tinnīn

staffs, ubiquitously employed on visual art from

and the dhanab al-tinnīn in the various astrologi-

the mid-eleventh to early thirteenth century and

cal tables included in his texts 87 Much earlier,

associated with the ancient concept of the “Master

in the work On The Great Conjunctions, or the

of the Dragons ” The choice of this cosmic sym-

Aḥkām Taḥāwīl Sinī al-Mawālid, the astrologer

bolism underlines the prominence accorded to

Abū Maʿshar (d 272/886) had already referred

jawzahar which gives an indication of the magni-

to the points of exaltation for the nodes of the

tude of the potential effects the planet could have

Moon which for the dragon’s head is in Gemini

on the course of human events The conception of

3°, and for the tail in Sagittarius 3° 88

the central figure as dragon-tamer thereby per-

The “node of the Moon’s orbit” however is an

haps reflects the apparent necessity to harness

integral part of the iconography of the eclipse

the forces of this planet

monster, portrayed as loop or twisted knot, some-

The planetary character of the two nodes of

times visualised as a pretzel- or heart-shaped

al-jawzahar indicates that they are traversing the

knot This is reflected in the symbolism of the

plane of the ecliptic With respect to the signs, the

personification of comets, Ketu, visualised on the

planets have a “domicilium” as well as a place of

navagraha reliefs that represent the nine Indian

exaltation (sharaf) and dejection (hubūṭ) These

planetary deities, which are similarly illustrated

astronomical terms respectively define the points

with a human torso and a serpentine tail termi-

most distant from and closest to the earth, espe-

nating in a knot 89 The earliest surviving repre-

cially in reference to the elliptical orbit of the

sentation of Rāhu and Ketu in India is carved

Moon In astrology they relate to the point of

on a navagraha lintel from Uttar Pradesh, dating

maximum and minimum influence of one of the

from c 600 or slightly later, in which Ketu is rep-

seven traditional planets and of the two nodes of

resented as a half-ophidian figure sitting on his

al-jawzahar when they find themselves in associa-

coiled serpentine tail beside the cephalic Rāhu

tion with one of the constellations visualised as

(fig 140) 90

one of the twelve signs of the zodiac

Individual depictions of jawzahar – Draco as

In the Irano-Turkish territories, the eclipse

eighth planet next to the seven traditional planets,

pseudo-planet (al-jawzahar) is often shown at the

comprising the Sun, the Moon, Saturn, Jupiter,

point of exaltation of its head or tail in Gemini,

Mars, Venus and Mercury,91 often portray a cross-

as for instance on a silver- and copper-inlaid

legged figure holding a dragon in each hand The

brass ewer from Herat, formerly in the Nuhad

85 Boilot, “al-Bīrūnī (Bērūnī), Abu ’l Rayḥān Muḥammad

probably dates from c 600 to 650 (Markel, 1995, fig 29;

b Aḥmad,” EI² I, 1136a

Government Museum, Alwar) For later depictions, see also

86 Tr and ed Wright, 1934, pp 91–2

Hartner, 1938, pp 134, 138, figs 6–8 For a discussion of the

87 Idem, pp 255, 258

navagraha reliefs, see Pingree, 1964–5, pp 249–67; Markel,

88 Hartner (1938, p 133 and n 30) refers to De magnis

1995, pp 19–68 and 129–76

91

coniunctionibus, the Latin version translated by Johannes

Hartner, 1938, pp 114–38 In later medieval Indian

Hispalensis, printed at Augsburg in 1489 (repr Venice,

literature both nodes, Rāhu (raʾs al-tinnīn), and Ketu (dhanab

1515), which contains a chapter dealing with the planetary

al-tinnīn), were attributed the same importance as the other

influence of the nodes as a figure of the “dragon” with its

seven planets, hence there were a total of nine planets; idem,

head and tail twisted around two nodes (reproduced in idem,

p 133, cf also p 151

92

fig 10) Cf al-Bīrūnī’s references in his Kitāb al-Tafhīm, tr

For instance, on a late twelfth- or early thirteenth-

and ed Wright, 1934, p 358

century copper alloy inkwell inlaid with silver from West-

89 Ketu’s serpent tail is alluded to in the Agnipurāṇa; see

ern Central Asia (Pugachenkova and Rempel’, fig 196, and

De Mallmann, 1962, p 86

fig 197, line drawing), or on a thirteenth-century silver-

90 The earliest western Indian representation is found on

inlaid copper alloy candlestick from Mesopotamia (Baer,

a fragmentary lintel from Alwar district in Rajasthan, which

1983, p 256, fig 208)

the dragon and astrology

141

Es-Said Collection, now in the National Museum

inhabited with monster heads with long floppy

of Qatar in Doha (fig 141) 93 In Islamic tradi-

ears growing from scrol ing tendrils (as shown for

tion, the planetary eclipse in Sagittarius is gen-

example in the depiction of “Moon in Cancer”)

erally rendered as a centaur taking aim with a

that Hartner identifies with “the dragon prog-

bow at its long dragon-headed tail and shooting

eny threatening the luminaries or, vicariously,

an arrow into the dragon’s mouth On the Qatar

their domicilia and exaltations ”96 However, he

ewer the sign is accordingly portrayed as the pro-

has qualified the astrological interpretation sug-

tome of a winged quadruped dragon with tongue

gesting that “in all probability, various elements

protruding from the gaping mouth rising from

– astronomical, astrological and mythologi-

the looped tail (fig 142) A sculptural example

cal – were here fused in one ”97 This shows that

of the planetary eclipse in Sagittarius is depicted

the astrological veracity of such details was less

among eight astrological reliefs carved onto the

important than their exemplary significance It is

pillars of the Tigris bridge, near the city of Jazīrat

moreover noteworthy that the monster heads with

ibn ʿUmar (present-day Cizre), Anatolia Among

long floppy ears issue from vegetation, which for

the reliefs is the upright knotted protome of a

its association with fertility generally has positive

dragon with gaping mouth and curled-up snout

connotations It may therefore be hypothesised

tip, oriented towards the figure of a centaur shoot-

that the depiction of “dragon progeny” together

ing with a bow and arrow into its mouth The

with the signs of the zodiac and the planets was

bridge was commissioned by the wazīr of Mosul,

intended to have a beneficial influence on the

Jamāl al-Dīn Muḥammad al-Iṣfahānī The wazīr’s

paths of the luminaries

imprisonment in 558/1163 provides a terminus

A related large silver-inlaid brass ewer, housed

ante quem for the construction of the bridge and

in the Georgian State Museum, Tbilisi, Georgia,

its astrological relief sculptures 94 As pointed out

which is decorated on the shoulder with the signs

by Hartner, the reliefs are one of the earliest-

of the zodiac and the planets, bears inscriptions

known sculptural examples “in which the Islamic

that not only give the name of the maker, one

artist obviously grants the same rights to one or

both of these pseudo-planets as to the seven real

Maḥmūd ibn Muḥammad al-Harawī and the

ones, while in India this had been the rule cen-

date, the month of Shaʿban 577/19 December

turies before ”95

1181–17 January 1182, but also state that the

Similarly, depictions of al-jawzahar threaten-

“seven heavenly bodies, however proud they may

ing the Sun and the Moon, or their respective

be, are protection for the one who works so ”98 As

zodiacal animals, the lion and the crab, became

James Allan states, “from this poem it is evident

prevalent in the decorative programmes of objects,

that the inlayer saw those images as protection

as evidenced in the depictions on the same ewer

for himself against evil ”99 It further underlines

(figs 143 and 144) The importance of the eclipse

the overall magical and prophylactic quality that

pseudo-planet is such that most of the roundels on

was ascribed to the iconography of the signs of

this ewer show the signs of the zodiac and planets

the zodiac and the planets The frequency of their

93 Jawzahar at the points of exaltation of its head or tail

astrological treatise, probably illustrated under Islamic

in Gemini is also depicted at the top of the lid of the penbox

influence in 1188; Amiranašvili, 1966, pl 56 See also

from Iran (signed by Maḥmūd ibn Sunqur on the hasp

p 19, n 36 A comparable figure is represented as centaur-

and dated 680/1281–2; on this penbox see also pp 96, 98

archer shooting an arrow backwards at the dragon head

and fig 93), which bears roundels in three groups of four

emerging from its tail on the coinage of the Artuqid

containing symbols of the zodiac with their ruling planets

ruler of Mardin, Nāṣir al-Dīn Artuq Arslan ibn Il Ghāzī

Cf Hartner, 1938, p 138 (misprint of dates), figs 14 and 15

(599/1203–637/1239); Roxburgh, ed 2004, p 398, cat

(roundel representing “Gemini”); idem, 1973–4, pp 115 and

no 86; What the Coins Tell Us, 2009, p 102; Hauptmann

fig 9 (left); Pope and Ackerman, eds , 1938–39, repr 1964–

von Gladiss, ed , 2006, pp 107–8, figs 15, 16 The same

81, vol 13, p 1336 B; Barrett, 1949, pl 33 top; Legacy, 2002,

emblem also figures on the coinage of the ʿAbbasid caliph

cat no 158, fig 46 The same motif is shown on an early

al-Nāṣir (577/1181–620/1223); eadem, 2006, p 107, cat

thirteenth-century copper alloy inkwell, inlaid with silver,

no 15

95

attributed to Iran or Syria, now in the Metropolitan Museum

Hartner, 1938, p 132

96

of Art, New york; cf Baer, 1983, p 257, fig 209 (detail of

Idem, 1959, pp 237–9, and idem, 1973–4, p 112, 118

97

p 79, fig 59)

Idem, 1973–4, pp 112–3

94

98

Meinecke, 1996, p 60 On the reliefs of Jazīrat ibn

Loukonine and Ivanov, 2003, pp 116–7, cat no 117

ʿUmar, see Preusser, 1911, pl 40; Hartner, 1938, p 134

(with the inscription in Arabic and English) Cf Allan,

and fig 2 (photograph at bottom left), and idem, 1973–4,

1982a, repr 1999, p 49; Atil, Chase, and Jett, 1985, p 17,

pp 108, 110; Gierlichs, 1996, pl 47 4 A Sagittarius rendered

fig 6 The translation given is based on the rendering by

as a centaur shooting an arrow towards his own tail which

Allan See also p 36, n 6

99

terminates in a dragon head is depicted in a Georgian

Allan, 1982a, repr 1999, p 49

142