The Dragon in Medieval East Christian and Islamic Art by Sara Kuehn, Sebastian Günther, et al - HTML preview

PLEASE NOTE: This is an HTML preview only and some elements such as links or page numbers may be incorrect.
Download the book in PDF, ePub, Kindle for a complete version.

chapter six

Mahābhārata, as well as episodes from the heroic

Correspondingly, Rustam is shown confronting

cycle, the dragon-fighter being identified by Alek-

the dragon as if it were a human adversary 95

sandr Belenitskii as the hero-champion Rustam 82

Igor P’yankov notes the archaic style of

The hero’s ancestors were Saka people who are

Firdawsī’s records of the Rustam cycle and has

part of the Scytho-Siberian cultural grouping and

demonstrated its close parallels with ancient

belong to the Indo-Iranian group that came to

Greek records, particularly Herodotus’ accounts

Sakastān/Sīstān and Zābulistān in the late second

of one of the genealogical myths of the Scyth-

century bc,83 lands far from Sogdia Saka heroic

ians ( Histories IV 8–9) 96 According to the father

tales were nevertheless very popular with the Sog-

of Greek historiography the hero, known by the

dians,84 although only a fragmentary Sogdian text

Greeks as Herakles, comes to an arid region at

survives85 and only in the tenth century was the

the Pontus Shore (Black Sea) later inhabited by

tale taken up by Firdawsī in his magnum opus The

the Scythians where he loses his horses and in

heroic cycle of Rustam’s Herculean seven feats

the search for them meets in a cave in the forest

(haft khwān) attains almost spiritual importance 86

a mythical creature described as a woman with

Before reaching his ultimate goal the hero has

the lower body of a serpent 97 With this anguipede

to undergo these trials,87 which represent a kind

woman he engenders three sons, the youngest and

of rite of passage 88 During his third feat, which

worthiest of whom, named Scythes, becomes the

is reminiscent of Herakles defeating the Hydra

first king of the Scythians In Firdawsī’s account

of Lerna,89 Rustam slays a magical dragon that

Rustam’s first feat is his victory over a lion whose

is guarding a watering place which the ram has

pelt he wears just like the Grecian Herakles after

shown90 and comes out of the forest at night and

the latter’s vanquishing of the Nemean lion 98

approaches the sleeping hero 91 Twice he is woken

The second exploit is the discovery of a spring

by his formidable mount Rakhsh,92 but each time

in the desert country 99 The third is the victory

the dragon vanishes On the third occasion the

over the dragon While there is no love theme in

monster fails to conceal itself in time and with the

the third trial, the fourth episode recorded in the

help of the faithful Rakhsh the hero succeeds in

Shāh-nāma mentions a sorceress in the form of a

killing the dragon Interestingly, the Shāh-nāma

beautiful girl who tries to seduce Rustam near a

portrays the dragon with human traits such as the

small river in the shade of some trees 100

power of reflection93 and speech: during the battle

Parts of the story are shown on a continuous

he declares himself master of the whole desert 94

frieze of the Sogdian wall paintings in Panjik-

82

88

Belenitskii, 1980, pp 103–5, 199 Cf Azarpay, 1981,

Cf Omidsalar, 2001, pp 262, 265–6

89

p 195 Guitty Azarpay (1981, pp 96–7) also points out that

For a discussion of the points of resemblance between

the “dramatis personae” were subject to change and not nec-

Hercules and Rustam, see Melikian-Chirvani, 1998, p 178

essarily connected to any specific hero

See also p 79, n 44

83

90

Boyce, 1975, repr 1996, p 101 and n 104; de Bruijn,

Shāh-nāma, tr and ed Mohl, 1838–1878, vol 1, p 515,

“Rustam,” EI 2 VIII, 636b; P’yankov, 2006, p 505

ll 336–41

84

91

P’yankov, 2006, pp 505–6

A view of the entire scene is reproduced in Azarpay,

85 The Sogdian fragment from Dunhuang which records

1981, p 96, fig 42 Shāh-nāma, tr and ed Mohl, 1838–1878,

part of the Rustam legend is fully quoted in Klíma, 1968,

vol 1, pp 517–21

92

p 53; Azarpay, 1981, pp 6–7 Cf Marshak, 2002, p 51

On the motif of the horse as helper of the hero, see

86 Cf Russell, 2004, p 543 and n 30 For a discussion of

Schirmunski, 1961, pp 25–6

93

the close parallels of the haft khwān (dragon slaying being

Shāh-nāma, tr and ed Mohl, 1838–1878, vol 1, p 517,

one of the exploits) of Rustam and Isfandiyār, see yarshater,

ll 565–70

94

1983a, pp 469–70 and n 5

Idem, vol 1, pp 519–21, ll 396–400 This exploit is also

87 The number seven was specifically important to the

recorded by the eleventh-century Armenian scholar Grigor

“Avestan people,” and plays a significant role in the rites and

Magistros who moreover notes that the battle took place near

customs of the Zoroastrians, for whom seven is the number

Mount Damāwand; see Tchukasizian, 1964, pp 321–2 Cf

of the creations and of the Amahraspands (Aməsha Spəntas),

P’yankov, 2006, p 507

95

the positive creatures or “Bounteous Immortals,” who guard

Tr and ed Mohl, 1838–1878, vol 1, pp 519–21, ll

them The number seven gained even greater prominence in

393–5, 400–2

96

the Islamic period, when it acquired additional symbolism

P’yankov, 2006, pp 505–11, esp pp 506–7

97

Cf Hartmann-Schmitz, 1989, pp 12–20; Schimmel, 1994,

Cf Sulimirski, 1985, p 168

98

p 27 Moreover, seven often conveys ideas of perfection

It is notable that the Nemean lion was one of the off-

and periodicity (for a list of examples, see Shahbazi, “Haft

spring of the drakōn Typhon and Echidna, who had the face

(seven),” EIr) It is a favourite number in eastern Semitic

and torso of a woman and the body of a serpent (Hesiod,

civilisations with magico-religious features; among the

Theogony 306–8) See West, 1962, p 161

99

Israelites it was used in ritual incantations (2 Kings 13 and

Tr and ed Mohl, 1838–1878, vol 1, pp 513–7

100

Joshua 6); and in the Old Testament seven is the number of

Idem, vol 1, pp 521–3

completeness Cf Jeffers, 1996, p 87, n 286

the dragon in scenes of combat

95

ent The monster is depicted as a terrifying she-

preserved in the National Museum in Dushanbe

dragon who has coiled her elongated serpentine

in Tajikistan 106 In one of the roundels a mounted

tail around all four legs of the horse (proba-

horseman is seen taking aim at a twice-knotted

bly to be understood as Rakhsh),101 her female

dragon 107

upper body rises up, naked to the waist With

While there appear to be no surviving repre-

her long arms she is dragging the mounted Rus-

sentations of the dragon-slayer around the turn of

tam-like hero’s head towards her The hero has

the millennium in the Islamic realm of Western

succeeded in wounding the dragon twice with

Asia, the equestrian dragon-fighter can nonethe-

his axe (fig 88) 102 In the next scene the dragon,

less be seen as a leitmotif which links the pre-

its wounds gushing blood, is in its death-throes

Islamic Sasanian and the Sogdian times with the

In contrast to the preceding images, it now

Islamic period After an apparent lacuna in the

lies prostrate on the ground (fig 89) 103 Boris

tenth and perhaps the early part of the eleventh

Marshak explains the depiction of the serpentine

century (a period during which the motif occurs

she-dragon with human arms and lion’s mane

in the Christian art of the Caucasus, particularly

as a conflation of three trials mentioned in the

in Armenia and Georgia, as examined below), it is

Shāh-nāma, namely the fight with the dragon,

depicted with great regularity on Islamic works of

the lion and the sorceress 104 While the genealogi-

art from Central Asia to Anatolia and the Jazīra

cal aspect of the myth was apparently forgotten,

The Abū Muslim-nāma,108 which records the

some analogies with the original theme of the

life of the charismatic Abū Muslim Khurāsānī

mythical anguipede progenitrix appear to have

(d c 137/754–5) who led a popular movement

been retained 105

for the ʿAbbasid cause and became a legendary

An equestrian dragon-fighter is also portrayed

figure after his assassination, recounts the heroic

on a tympanum from the medieval city of Bunji-

exploits of the fourth caliph ʿAlī ibn Abī Ṭālib

kat (20 kilometres south of the modern town of

(d 40/660), Muḥammad’s cousin who married

Shahristan in northern Tajikistan) in the Sog-

the Prophet’s daughter Fāṭima ʿAlī is portrayed

dian principality of Ustrushana, probably dating

as accomplishing the feat of vanquishing the

from the seventh to the ninth century A row of

dragon at a very early age and is eulogised as

pearl roundels frame the rim of the monumental

infant dragon-slayer with the words:

wooden arch-shaped tympanum (partly destroyed

by fire) that adorned the top of the portal leading

Bare-handed in the cradle with his mighty arms

to the throne hall of the Qalʿa-i Qahqaha, now

he tore apart the dragon’s jaws 109

101

107

Comparable imagery is represented on a Sasanian

The first fire is associated with the time of the ʿAbbasid

seal in the British Museum, London, which shows a dou-

conquest of the town in 206/822, the second with the annex-

ble-headed serpent coiled around each of the four legs of a

ation to the Samanid state by Ismāʿīl ibn Aḥmad I (279/892–

bovine and rearing up above its head and inscribed with the

295/907) providing a terminus ante quem for the dating of

name of the owner in Pahlawī Mordtmann, 1864, pl I, no 4,

the wooden panel

108

republished in Ettinghausen, 1955, p 282, pl XXXIX, no 8

The Abū Muslim-nāma was written by Abū Ṭāhir

Cf Bivar, 1969, p 8, pl 15 1; Marshak, 2002, p 43

Ṭarsūsī (Ṭūsī), who was part of the retinue of the Turkic

102 Azarpay, 1981, pl 6; Marshak, 2002, p 40, figs 17–20,

Ghaznawid sulṭān Maḥmūd (r 389/999–421/1030) The leg-

colour pl 3; Grube and Johns, 2005, p 233, cat no 78 5

ends of Abū Muslim are surveyed in Mélikoff, 1962 See also

103 Azarpay, 1981, pl 7; Marshak, 2002, p 43, fig 20

eadem, 1960, vol 1, p 43

104

109

Idem, 2002, p 51 An anachronical but perhaps not

The translation is based on the manuscript in Paris,

entirely irrelevant parallel exists in Kushāṇa-period chthonic

Bibliothèque Nationale, Ms Pers 843, dated 1145–6/1732–4;

creatures, sometimes referred to as vyāla, which were rep-

Mahdjoub, 1988, p 63 The motif of the infant dragon-slayer

resented as half-females, half-serpents, with a female upper

is repeatedly found in classical literature, for instance, in

body whose lower limbs transform into a long spiralling

the depiction of the infant hero Herakles struggling with

serpentine tail terminating in a fan-shaped caudal fin Cf

two serpents described by the classical Greek poet Pindar

Czuma, 1985, p 53, cat no 3

( c. 518–438 bc) in the Nemean Ode 1, 42–7 Another early

105 Igor P’yankov (2006, pp 508–10) notes that traces of

classical example is given by the infant Apollo who when

the ancient genealogical tales are still preserved in today’s

only a few days old shot arrows from the arms of his mother

folklore of southern Tajikistan where the Scythian people once

Leto at a multi-headed snake, the story being depicted on

lived and where he heard oral traditions from local people

a fifth-century bc lekythos (predating Euripides’ Iphigeneia

about a dangerous serpentine woman who lives in the river

in Tauris, 1239–1251); see Fontenrose, 1959, repr 1980,

106 Unfortunately, the panel remains unpublished; it

pp 16–7 and fig 1 For a discussion of the epic motif of

was not permitted to photograph it in the museum nor was

the supernatural power and acquisition of “wisdom” and

it possible to obtain a photograph from the museum For

certain magical abilities of infant heros from dragons, see

a description of the site, see Negmatov, 1996, repr 1999,

Schirmunski, 1961, pp 58–9

pp 259–74, and fig 41

96