The Dragon in Medieval East Christian and Islamic Art by Sara Kuehn, Sebastian Günther, et al - HTML preview

PLEASE NOTE: This is an HTML preview only and some elements such as links or page numbers may be incorrect.
Download the book in PDF, ePub, Kindle for a complete version.

chapter six

It is interesting to compare this imagery with

was often chosen as part of a visual narrative on

that of the infant Rustam whose arms are asso-

metalwork, for instance on the two copper alloy

ciated with courageous dragons in the Shāh-nāma

buckets discussed above, the 559/1163 Bobrinski

account 110

bucket probably from Herat, and the late twelfth-

The theme of the dragon-slayer appears in a

to early thirteenth-century richly gilded bucket

mid-twelfth-century book on cosmography writ-

made by Muḥammad ibn Nāṣir ibn Muḥammad

ten in Persian and dedicated to the last Great Saljuq

al-Harawī, also perhaps from Herat The third

sulṭān of Iran and Iraq, Ṭoghrıl III ibn Arslan (r

figural relief that circumscribes the body of the

571/1176–590/1194) The story in Muḥammad

Bobrinski bucket also comprises a procession of

ibn Maḥmūd ibn Aḥmad-i Ṭūsī’s “Book of Mar-

riders Behind one of the mounted warriors, a

vels,” entitled ʿAjāʾib al-makhlūqāt (“Wonders of

“Saljuq-style” twice looped dragon with enormous

Creation”),111 illustrates the power of talismanic

gaping mouth rears up threateningly (fig 90), its

images hidden in the pre-conquest Byzantine

tongue with bifid tip oriented towards the back

capital Constantinople (al-Qusṭantīniyya) 112

of the horseman, the scaly body echoing the body

Three bronze statues representing Muḥammad

of the dragon protome on the handle (fig 56) A

and two of his closest followers, ʿAlī and Bilāl

second rider charges from behind to assist the

(the first muezzin), were zealously guarded by

beleaguered warrior, wielding what appear to be

the local people; they knew from past experience

a shield and a club The body of the Fould bucket

that damage to the statues would set off a dev-

is divided into twelve barely perceptible vertical

astating earthquake 113 Significantly, of the three

facets, alternately enclosing a cartouche forming

statues only the one which shows ʿAlī on horse-

an angular figure of eight framed by a benedic-

back striking a dragon with a spear is illustrated

tory epigraphic band in Kufic and enclosing riders

in the manuscript 114 While on the one hand this

mounted on camels, horses and mules or don-

story is buttressed by apocalyptic traditions, such

keys One of the horsemen, a curved sabre raised

as the prophetic ḥadīth foretelling the city’s cap-

above his head, turns backwards to defend him-

ture by an Islamic ruler who bore the name of a

self against an upright dragon of a type closely

prophet,115 it is also noteworthy that it was the

related to the one featured on the Bobrinski

Byzantine capital which was associated with the

bucket, who threatens him with open jaws from

figure of the equestrian dragon-slayer However,

behind (fig 91) 116 The prevalence of the motif on

the story also shows that the dragon-fighter repre-

Western Central Asian metalwork is further sug-

sented a well-established iconographical theme in

gested by a related depiction in which the dragon

medieval Islam It was indeed so firmly entrenched

is shown with a curved horn on an early twelfth-

as to be deemed the most appropriate imagery

century Herati-type copper alloy ewer inlaid with

for the representation of the Companion of the

silver from a private collection (fig 92)

Prophet who for the Sunnī Muslims represents

A variant of the motif is found on the base of

the fourth caliph and for the Shīʿites the divinely

a well-known copper alloy penbox (qalamdān)

appointed successor (khalīfa) and heir (waṣī) of

inlaid in silver, gold and niello from Iran, which

Muḥammad

bears the name Maḥmūd ibn Sunqur and the

By the twelfth century, dragon-fighter ico-

date 680/1281–2 inscribed on the hasp Here not

nography was a prevalent part of a set narra-

the single equestrian fighter but a second genus,

tive genre often inspired by textual sources such

that of the paired horsemen, is reproduced Two

as the early eleventh-century Iranian national

scenes of confronted fighting horsemen, separated

epic, the Shāh-nāma, and was a motif of choice

by three large roundels fil ed with a geometric pat-

depicted on many portable objects produced

tern, are shown: on the scene to the left one horse-

in medieval Western Central Asia The theme

man attacks an upright double-headed dragon

110 Tr and ed Mohl, 1838–1878, vol 5, p 353, ll 1707–9

Pancaroğlu, 2003, pp 33, 37 and appendix

111

113

Ed Sotūde, M , Tehran, 1345/1966, as cited in

Eadem, pp 34, 37

114

Pancaroğlu (2003, p 31 and n 4) who dates the book to the

First section of chapter six (Aḥmad-i Ṭūsī, ʿAjāʾib

years between 562/1167 and 573/1194 Cf Radtke, 1987,

al-makhlūqāt, ed Sotūde, M , Tehran, 1345/1966, pp 333–4);

pp 278–88

eadem, pp 34, 37 and appendix

112

115

First section of chapter six which includes descrip-

See, for instance, Eisener, 1987, pp 129–37 Cf

tions on talismanic portraits, statues and tombs of prophets

Pancaroğlu, 2004, p 155

116

and kings (ed Sotūde, M , Tehran, 1345/1966, pp 333–4);

Cf Mayer, 1959, pl X

the dragon in scenes of combat

97

with a sword while the other turns backwards to

sels (so-called mīnāʾī ware) featuring a richly

shoot a lion with bow and arrow (fig 93) 117 The

clad dragon-fighting rider, his mount decorated

vertically oriented body of the dragon is char-

with magnificent trappings On a star tile, now in

acterised by bilateral symmetry, the addorsed

the Freer Gallery of Art, Washington, DC, the

heads with open jaws revealing projecting tongues

sinuous speckled dragon is shown in a downward

and the scaly body bifurcating to form two loops

diagonal (fig 95),119 whereas on a bowl from the

before uniting and thinning to a short pointed

Vollmoeller Collection in Zurich it is rendered

tip On the right, two horsemen charge at each

in the more conventional supine posture, jaws

other with long lances The depictions are set

agape, tongue projecting and the serpentine body

against a background filled with a dense interlace

arranged in two loops (fig 96) 120 The ophidian

of foliate scrolls bearing long-eared animal heads

bodies are both demarcated with a dense pattern

that have been identified as “dragon progeny ”118

On the tile the horseman seems to take aim with a

Another example with the motif survives in

bow, while on the bowl the cavalier probably bran-

the form of a twelfth- or thirteenth-century richly

dishes a sword Another example of the depiction

gilt copper alloy polylobed openwork roundel,

of a horseman fighting an upright dragon is part

probably a fitting from a belt or horse-harness

of the main narrative frieze circumscribing the

for attachment, now in the al-Sabāh Collection,

shoulders of a contemporary moulded flask in

Kuwait National Museum The roundel depicts an

the Aga Khan Collection 121

elaborately dressed archer on the back of a pranc-

The belief in the invulnerability of a dragon’s

ing horse which has a knotted tail and carefully

hide, which is impervious to water, fire, or any

rendered trappings, studded with circular phale-

weapon, explains why the hero usually aims at

rae and suspended crescents A feline, probably a

the head, eyes or mouth of the dragon or has

cheetah, crouches behind the warrior, who draws

to attack him from within 122 This is particu-

his bow and takes aim at a dragon as it writhes

larly evident in one of the celebrated feats of

below the feet of his mount (fig 94) The serpen-

Rustam in the legend of the battle with the Babr-i

tine body is enlivened by a dense dotted pattern

bayān 123 As a young man Rustam was fighting the

and arranged in two loops

beast in a distant land and managed to kill the

Of the same period and from the same wider

dragon by making it swallow oxhides filled with

geographical region stem related depictions

quicklime and stones124 which he carried to the

on polychrome painted ceramic tiles or ves-

place where once a week the dragon came out of the

117 Cf Furūsiyya, 1996, vol 1, p 173, fig IVa detail to left,

As cited by Klíma, 1968, p 12, after the German translation

and IV view of entire lid, vol 2, p 232, cat no 194

of Wolff, F , Avesta: Die Heiligen Bücher der Parsen, Straß-

118 Hartner, 1959, pp 237–9, and idem, 1973–4, pp 112,

burg, first ed 1910, repr 1924; see also Boyce, 1975, repr

118

1996, pp 102–3 The long time lapse before the heat began to

119 In its unrestored condition the tile has been published

permeate the dragon’s hide to finally wake him up (Skjærvø,

in Atil, 1973, cat no 49, and Grube and Johns, 2005, p 233,

“Aždahā I,” EIr) suggests, according to Khāleqī-Moṭlaq

cat no 78 7

(“Aždahā II,” EIr), “that the belief in the invulnerability of the

120 Another example of a mīnāʾī bowl with the same ico-

dragon-hide was a very old component of the story ” Having

nography featuring the dragon head rising above the horse’s

finally defeated the dragon, the hero, like Rustam, also made

head is preserved in the Calouste Gulbenkian Foundation,

a coat out of its hide It is noteworthy that similarly many

Lisbon Curatola, 1989, fig 63

early epic heroes were distinguished with a magical invulner-

121 Splendori a corte, 2007, p 149, cat no 117 (the dragon-

ability apart from one vulnerable spot, for instance Isfandiyār

fighting theme is not featured on the side of the flask that has

in the Shāh-nāma who is invulnerable apart from his eyes,

been reproduced in the catalogue)

and so a double-pointed arrow has to be discharged into

122 In the Avesta (yasht 9 10–1) a similar story of the

them in order to wound or kill him Cf Schirmunski, 1961,

invulnerability of the dragon’s hide is recorded, according to

pp 36–7

123

which Kərəsāspa/Garshāsp cooked his midday meal on the

Two versions of the legend are found in a Shāh-nāma

vast green flank of the sleeping Azhi Sruuara (Azhi Zairita):

manuscript in the British Museum, London (Ms Or 2926,

fols 112b-115a and 118b-122b); it is also current in surviv-

He was a young man famous for his strength, had

ing Iranian oral folklore (Enjavī, A , Mardom o Shāh-nāma,

curly hair and swung his club; he smote the horny

Tehran, 1355/1976, pp 217–8, cited after Khāleqī-Moṭlaq,

dragon, the horse-swallowing and man-swallowing,

“Aždahā II,” EIr); a variant of the story is known among the

full of poison, yellow of colour, over whom yellow

Mandeans of Iraq (Petermann, 1860–1, vol 2, pp 107–9)

124

poison flowed as high as a spear On his back Kərəsāspa

In the Shāh-nāma this method of killing the dragon

cooked his meal in an iron cauldron at the time of

is similarly employed by Iskandar (tr and ed Mohl, 1838–

noon And the monster felt warm and began to sweat

1878, vol 4, pp 203–5, ll 1230–1249) Analogies may be

Then he rushed from under the iron cauldron and

found in other mythological traditions such as the story of

upset the boiling water Affrighted rushed headlong

Bel and the Dragon in the book of Daniel LXX in which there

the valiant Kərəsāspa

was a giant serpent (drakōn) that was venerated by the Baby-

98