support by giving away parts of the solution (Winnips, 1998, p.
35). But always this support is faded, so that the learner will
become self-reliant.
In the table below, the three concepts are compared to each
other.
Modeling
Coaching
Scaffolding
Support to
To present a help the
desired
Giving support in
performance
behaviour or
order to help the
of a task. It is
Definition
process so
performance of a
aimed at
that it can be
task, whereby this
improving the
imitated by
support is faded.
performance
the learner. of the learner.
An expert
Students
Students design a
designer
design a
product, an expert
thinking
product, an
designer monitors
aloud during expert
their progress,
Example
the design of designer
solves problems
a product,
monitors their together with the
thereby
progress,
students, motivates
pointing out solves
students, and
830
critical
problems
points them
aspects and together with towards different
important
the students, directions, during
decisions
motivates
the process of
during
students, and designing students
design.
points them take over the
Afterwards towards
responsibility, and
students try different
are left to
to imitate
directions.
themselves by the
this
expert.
behaviour.
A sequence in a
studybook
describing
concepts at an
increasingly higher
level of
understanding,
aimed at keeping
the level of
difficulty equal
during learning
Counter-
-
-
(such as a simple-
example
to-complex
sequence).
Scaffolding is
interactive. This
means that fading
reacts to the level
of an individual
student or group of
students, and that
it is tailored to
their current level
831
of understanding.
So, the sequence of
events in
scaffolding can not
be described
beforehand.
Modeling focusses on imitation of the performance of an expert,
coaching focusses on the performance of the learner (Jonassen,
1998). Scaffolding can use these two and adds the aspect of
fading. The support that is given by modeling performance, the
support that is given by coaching, or other types of support given
are faded so that the learner becomes self-reliant.
Modeling
NLP Modeling is the process of recreating excellence. We can
model any human behavior by mastering the beliefs, the
physiology and the specific thought processes (that is the
strategies) that underlie the skill or behavior.
It is about achieving an outcome by studying how someone else
goes about it.
When Richard Bandler and John Grinder modeled the strategies
of Virginia Satir, they were trying to achieve what many others
before them had attempted. They wanted to duplicate her
extraordinary results in family therapy.
What Bandler and Grinder did differently was to find the
thinking strategies she was using, rather than merely copy
behaviors. The biggest problem interviewing experts is that
skills are usually unconscious. We can not explain how we walk,
talk or write for instance. What makes you a successful parent or
golfer? The expert's own theories explain their success. These
theories can include irrelevant habits and superstitions such as
sportsmen and their lucky socks.
832
NLP Modeling involves transferring what an expert thinks they
know and what they unconsciously know. It involves being able
to produce the outcome and transferring the behavior to others.
The use of modeling in NLP does not just involve extraordinary
skills. For example, you could model how someone keeps her
desk clean. We can use the same key questions to find out how
someone keeps himself depressed, or becomes frustrated.
There are three phases to modeling
1. Observing the model
This involves fully imagining yourself in someone else's reality
by using what NLP calls a second position shift.
The focus is on "what" the person does (behavior and
physiology), "how" they do it (internal thinking strategies) and
"why" they do it (supporting beliefs and assumptions).
We obtain the "what" from direct observation. The "how" and
"why" is gained by asking quality questions. Deep trance
identification is a powerful tool to accomplish this part of the
process. It involves using unconscious clues to generate more
information than can be obtained logically.
NLP modeling components
The NLP Techniques skills and Presuppositions enable success in
modeling. These involve observing the model's:
o
Representational Systems (audio, visual, kine)
o
Strategies
o
Physiological components (like states and body postures)
o
Meta Programs, beliefs and values
o
Reference structures - the necessary background knowledge
2. Find the difference that makes the difference
Traditional learning adds pieces of a skill one bit at a time until
we have them all. The drawback to this method is we don't know
833
which bits are essential. By contrast modeling which is the basis
of accelerated learning, gets all the elements and then subtracts
to find what is necessary.
By systematically taking out elements of the model's behavior,
we can find what pieces are essential. If the process still works
without that element, it is not relevant.
The important questions are:
o
What are the behavioral patterns of the successful person?
o
How does she achieve her results?
o
What did she do that is different from a person who is not
successful?
o
What is the difference that makes the difference?
When you have all the pieces, you can refine and sequence the
model.
3. Design a method to teach the skill
Until you have all the relevant pieces of a skill and the necessary
sequence, you cannot teach it effectively. We currently teach
many skills with extra background information and pieces
muddying the waters.
Rehearsal of the natural sequence of the skill is important. If you
tried to make a cake by putting it in the oven before mixing the
ingredients together, it would be yucky. Yet we think we can
teach separate elements of skills out of sequence and out of
context and succeed.
NLP Modeling is a powerful process that can accelerate learning
of skills. Strong modeling practices are the basis of good NLP
training.
Personally I would replace the word modeling with copying. You
have
to
copy
what
others
have
done
before.
"The movers and shakers of the world are often professional
modelers (copiers) - people who have mastered the art of
834
learning everything they can by following other people's
experience rather than their own".
In other words if you can think, act and so on like someone else
you can duplicate their success.
So you are ready to programme your brain, use the right body
posture, copy someone else but what do you have to do first?
You've got to decide what it is you actually want from life, that's
what. This is quite difficult, but you've got to be brave,and get it
all down on paper.and think along the lines of, "If you knew you
wouldn't fail what would you do?"
This is to free our mind of limitations. Many of us think we can't
do something because of lots of negative thoughts we have
accepted over the years
How do we get rid of all of these limiting thoughts? By replacing
the pictures in our brain/mind/head with positive pictures.
The pictures of how we think things are can be manipuated. We
can look at them and make them darker or smaller until they
fade away and replace them with new brighter, bigger positive
pictures. This book will tell you how.
Source:
http://www.squidoo.com/unlimited-power
835
3.54 PROBLEM ANALYSIS
Identify problems; recognize significant information; gather and
coordinate relevant data; diagnose possible causes.
Behavioral statements:
Take well planned steps to gather and organize data for
diagnostic purposes.
Distinguish the grade of problems and to indicate major
issues.
Foresee problems and to judge their relevance.
Ask for questions and ensure they are answered.
836
Basic Problem Definition
Step 1
Step 2
Step 3
Get a written list Define who
Separate the "real"
containing 5 - 9 wants to solve
problems from the
answers to the
each problem,
symptoms and
question:
who cares how it proposed solutions.
is solved and
A "real" problem has
"What is the
who might resist multiple potential
problem?"
the solution.
solutions. A good
from each
solution will cause all
Identify the
involved party.
related symptoms to
players by role
disappear.
or job title, not
name.
If necessary, apply
problem/symptom
reduction.
Problem/Symptom Reduction
STEP 1: Ask each involved party,
"What is wrong with how things work today?"
Capture the answers as a numbered list of potential problem
statements expressed as complete sentences.
STEP 2: For each problem statement on your list, ask,
837
"Can anyone involved with the project do anything about it?"
If not, move it to an "out of scope" list to be reported back to
management.
STEP 3: For each problem statement on your reduced list, ask,
"Can anyone on the project identify multiple (different)
solutions?" If there is only one solution, the statement is an
implied requirement. Rephrase the statement and move it to the
requirement list.
STEP 4: For each problem statement on the remaining list, ask,
"If this problem were solved, would any other problem go
away?"
A "problem" that disappears when you solve a different problem
is a symptom. Associate the symptom with the related problem.
Any problem statement that is still on the list is considered a
"real" problem. These are the problems that any solution needs
to address while making sure that all of the identified symptoms
disappears
Good questions for analysing and solving of problems
Questions are used to open possibilities, to clarify meaning, and
to structure the progression through the four stages of problem
solving. Particular types of questions are most beneficial at each
stage of the problem solving process.
838
o Problem articulation and framing: What questions are best at
this stage; they allow the group to gather details and
descriptions of the situation and help members understand the
real problem and thus reframe it in a way that everyone can
agree upon. For example, what is the most important thing…?
o Problem analysis stage: At this stage why questions are most
helpful; questions such as why is that important? Why do you
think it happened? Why were you feeling that way?
o Hypothesis generation or diagnosis stage: how questions allow
the group or individual to begin to formulate a tentative theory
to explain or address the problem: how is this situation similar
to or different from other problems? How could you do things
differently? How could we intervene?
o Action stage: At this stage, the group may be seeking to
describe behavior (test for different behaviors) or to share
inferences (test for different views); what questions become
important again. What are the implications of all this for future
action? What should you do now?
At any stage of the problem solving process, a team can get stuck,
not seeing a way forward. To help shake things up so that the
team can see things from a new perspective and move forward,
it’s useful to ask the following types of questions:
o Open-ended questions: Unlike closed questions, which seek a
short, specific response like yes or no, open ended questions
encourage people to expand ideas and allow exploration of
what’s important to them or what is comfortable for them to
reveal. Asking open ended questions also encourages them to do
the work of self reflection and problem solving rather than
justifying or defending a position. For example: what do you
think…? Could you say more about…? What possibilities come to
mind? What might happen if you…?
839
o Clarification questions: When someone is not clear or you do
not experience the full understanding of the situation, you might
ask the person to define or explain the statement. For example:
Let me see if I am clear. Are you talking about…? Are you
saying…? Could you say that in different words?
o Questions for details: When someone is not clear, you might
ask for further bits of information. For example: More
specifically, what are some of the things that you have tried?
Have you asked so and so what his major concerns are? Does
thus and such agree that there are performance problems?
o Stimulating questions: Introduce ideas and options by asking
questions rather than suggesting a course of action. Emphasis is
on asking, rather than telling, inviting a thoughtful response and
maintaining a spirit of collaboration. For example: Let me see if
I’m clear. Are you talking about setting goals based upon your
feedback? This implies that person should use feedback as a
guide to setting goals. Similarly, have you asked so and so what
his concerns are? Can be used to offer someone the option of
inviting so and so to speak about his priorities.
o Probing questions: go below the level of events and behaviors
to search for internal drivers that trigger a person’s behavior.
For example: Why did this happen? Why did you believe this
would be the result?
o Summarizing questions: Invite others to complete or end the
discussion with questions that capture the key issues of action.
For example: What is the major point that has been made here?
840
Source:
Leading With Questions
How Leaders Find the Right Solutions by Knowing What to Ask
Notes by Frumi Rachel Barr, MBA, Ph.D.
Author: Michael Marquardt - Publisher: Jossey-Bass
Copyright year: 2005 - ISBN: 10:0-7879-7746-2
ceoconfidante@frumi.com www.100mustreads.com 17
ceoconfidante@frumi.com www.100mustreads.com 18
841
3.55 POSITIVITY
Our positive spirit is the Adventurer in us. It is the part of us that
glimpses what we are capable of. Through learning how to think
positively about our goals, and to act positively in our daily
habits, we attract to ourselves all the means which make our
goals achievable. Here are 7 ways to become more positive.
1. Create A Positive Self-Image
Your self-image is the person you think you are. You are your
own creation. When your self-image is low, you attract into your
life all the experiences and conditions that tell you how poor you
are. Conversely, when your self-image is high, you attract
experiences telling you how great you are. The easiest way to
create the self-image you want is through your self-talk. Simply
control the chatter in your head. Boost your morale regularly,
morning, noon, and night with what you tell yourself.
2. Talk In Terms Of Positive Goals
Our brains need images of positive goals to work towards. They
become confused if we feed them negative goals. So, if it is your
aim to give up smoking, don’t say: “I want to stop smoking”.
Instead, say “I want to enjoy a pleasant evening out with a couple
of refreshing drinks, breathing in fresh, revitalizing, clean, pure,
uncontaminated, healthy air.”
3. Have Positive Expectations
Numerous experiments confirm the truth that when you expect
the best, you usually get the best, and when you expect the
worst, you usually get that too. This is known as the self-
prophesying principle. So, at the start of any new enterprise or at
the start of each new day, look forward with expectations of the
very best.
842
4. Always Review Positively
If we are positive at the start of an enterprise, we should be
equally positive at the end when we review. Many people
become discouraged when things don’t go to plan and they beat
themselves up for missing out on the one thing that didn’t work.
But there are always gems of real worth in every situation, even
apparent disasters, if we only look hard enough. One way to
review positively is to use igniter phrases rather than
chloroform phrases. So, an obstacle is not a “barrier” but a
“challenge”; a setback is not a “disaster” but a “chance to learn”;
and a tough problem is not a “failure”, but “a nut we’re going to
crack”.
5. Mix With Positive People
One of the biggest drains on our enthusiasms is to be surrounded
by people who are negative. They may be well-meaning with
their warnings but they are misguided. You have two choices if
you want to survive as a positive person: avoid them or train
them. One clever way to train negative people is to simply ignore
them when they use discouraging conversation. Simply blank
them. Then when they return to positive expressions, re-connect.
Very soon, they will learn that you are a person who has a sunny
disposition and they will simply drop their previously gloomy
attitude with you.
6. Use Positivity For Good Health
Emile Coue, the founder of auto-suggestion, carried out a
number of studies that proved that positive thinking can cure
both mental and physical pain. George Gallup in his study of old
age also found that a positive attitude was one of the key
ingredients of long living. More recent studies have shown that
brain cells actually shrivel up and die under the effect of negative
thinking while positive thinking actually changes the
843
composition of body cells for the better. Which all goes to show
that positivity is better than any medicine you could buy from
the chemist store.
7. Get The Positivity Habit
Good habits are as easy to make as bad ones. It’s simply a matter
of choice and repetition. So, if you want the positivity habit in
your life, do these things every day:
• dress the best you can
• smile more
• try to genuinely like others
• give people positive strokes of recognition
• give people the most precious gift you have: more of your time
• be thankful for everything you get.
Positivity is not a Pollyanna-ish rose-tinted view of things which
ignores reality, but a choice we make about thinking, acting, and
speaking which creates reality. As such, it has the power of
magic.
844
3.56 HEAD ON COLLISION
A client has pent-up emotion buried under denial, rationalization
and minimizing. "Hey, no one had a perfect childhood, it's no big
deal," he says, "it is what it is." What happens next? If his
therapist was trained in ISTDP, the client better make sure his
seatbelt is fastened.
Intensive Short-Term Dynamic Psychotherapy (ISTDP) was
developed in the 1960's by Dr. Habib Davanloo, a psychiatrist
who agreed with the basic tenets of psychoanalysis but became
frustrated with the length of time it required. He developed a
modality where the therapist becomes a much more active agent
of change and where resistance is handled directly and firmly. He
believed that when people push through the resistance and
experience true, intense emotion about the past and present,
psychological
symptoms
diminish
and
interpersonal
relationships improve.
The therapist, who knows how to spot a defense when she sees
one, jumps in and confronts the client with his resistance, points
out consequences of remaining defended (which may include
lost time, money and relationships) and presents him with a
choice.
Here's an example of a Head-On Collision, one that could be
applied to the client at the beginning of the article:
Let's take a look at what's happening here. You have come on
your own free will, because you are experiencing a
Reads:
80
Pages:
83
Published:
Sep 2024
Are you having trouble connecting with women in a meaningful way? Do you find it difficult to attract the right partner or feel confident in conversations? Ar...
Formats: PDF, Epub, Kindle, TXT